The MFA in Creative Writing: The Uses of a “Useless” Credential

Abstract

Over half of today's Masters of Fine Arts programs in creative writing in the United States were founded after the year 2000. Has the MFA-CW become a necessary credential for novelists? Relying on participant observation field research in the American literary field and interviews with authors, publishers, MFA graduates, and instructors, this work focuses on a paradox: Despite widespread agreement that the credential doesn't "teach" enrollees to be a good writers or open up a pathway to a professional writing career, many involved in the literary field hold an MFA-CW. In this paper, we look at the uses of the MFA-CW, finding that although the degree serves little if any jurisdictional or closure-related functions it is made useful in a variety of ways: for students as a symbolic resource for artistic identity, for working writers as a source of income and community, and for editors in publishing houses as a signal for possible marketing and publicity potential.

Cultural Capital: Arts Graduates, Spatial Inequality, and London’s Impact on Cultural Labor Markets

“…Indeed, even those who have argued most eloquently for the importance of the arts school as a route into the CCIs (e.g., Banks & Oakley, 2016;Childress & Gerber, 2015;Frith & Horne, 1987) have not done so on the grounds of credentialization, but of socialization. In the milieu of the art school in the 1970s and 1980s, the role of the institution was as much about commitment to a cultural practice and the creation of a "scene," as it was about formalized, targeted, or vocational education.…”

Different ways of descending into the crypt: methodologies and methods for researching creative writing

“… The mystique of writers' processes is destroyed by analysis (Light 1996: 3)  Creative writing is essentially a 'recreational' activity and of little importance in the 'real' world (Childress & Gerber 2015: Hesse 2010  Creative writing processes resist research because they are ultimately different for every writer, and therefore no 'generalisable' knowledge can be drawn from examining them (Hesse 2010: 32) In addressing these arguments, it is worth raising the question of how creative writing processes are defined. Creative writing has been researched in the form of literary criticism for centuries.…”

Occupations and Professionalism in Art and Culture

“…Atti-www.professionsandprofessionalism.com Page 4 tudes epitomized in the reversed economy represent the actual entry into the field and would not exist without the field itself (Broady, 2012, p. 9). Bourdieu's field theory is in this issue employed in the contributions by Flisbäck and Lund (2015), Lindström (2015), and Childress and Gerber (2015). Although the occupations discussed in these articles represent different sub-fields within the broader field of creative work, there is a common approach to the struggle for autonomy among practising actors in relation to the fields of economy and politics.…”