The Integration of Indigenous Knowledge for Disaster Risk Reduction Practices through Scientific Knowledge: Cases from Mentawai Islands, Indonesia

Abstract

This study explores the importance of indigenous knowledge for everyday practices of disaster risk reduction and response. Many existing studies have highlighted the need to integrate such knowledge with modern science. Based on ethnographic research in indigenous communities in the Mentawai Islands of Indonesia, this study explores the categorization of indigenous knowledge in the integration process. To that end, primary data were collected through in-depth interviews while secondary data were collected from relevant documents, including books, articles, websites and government and NGO reports. The findings indicate that indigenous knowledge is acquired through long observation and interaction with disasters. Although some of this knowledge is based on successes in other localities, some indigenous knowledge is completely local, homogenous and shared among community members. It was also established that indigenous knowledge can be meaningfully organized into a number of categories, and that indigenous knowledge of a technical nature is more likely to be integrated with scientific knowledge. The research was exploratory and approached indigenous knowledge issues from the point of view of indigenous communities themselves. This approach should be replicated and expanded in other indigenous communities.

Pandemics and Sustainable Human Nature Relations: A Case study in Baduy Community, South Banten, Indonesia

“…In other words, mitigation procedures for the Covid-19 disease disaster are carried out by integrating local knowledge and Western scientific knowledge, which is considered appropriate with current conditions. Some studies cross-culture in the world also show that it is important to integrate local knowledge and Western scientific knowledge for natural resource management and the environment or disaster mitigation [5,21,28,29,45,46,56]. Therefore, multi-disciplinary and interdisciplinary studies, such as ethnobiology and ethnoecology, are important to do intensively, because the results are important for the development of science and practical results can be used to support the sustainable development programs, such as conservation of nature, adaptive agricultural development to various environmental changes, and management of infectious diseases [28].…”

Cultural strategies of the local and transmigrant communities in dealing with land and forest fire disasters in West Kotawaringin District, Central Kalimantan, Indonesia

“…Studies on the role of TEK in relation to risk management and reduction as well as the response to disasters, including climate changes and cross-culture around the world, have been performed by different researchers worldwide (Hop et al 2017;Rai and Kawas 2019;Zulfadrim et al 2019;Hosen et al 2020;Magalhaes et al 2021;Sekaranom et al 2021). However, studies on the cultural strategies of the different cultural backgrounds in dealing with disasters have rarely been undertaken.…”

Consensus of Local Knowledge on landslide Hazard in Depopulated Mountain Communities in Japan – A Case Study on Matsunoyama Village

“…In Japan, the significance of indigenous/local knowledge in disaster risk reduction was emphasized by scholars related to different disaster events during past decades. For example, a story is told and believed to have been handed down by an ancestor who lived in the Sanriku region of Japan, a tsunami-prone area that saved many lives in the Great East Japan Earthquake in March 2011 (Zulfadrim et al 2019). These phenomena describe how local knowledge is vital in disaster risk reduction among communities applying local knowledge to prevent disastrous events.…”