Sports media professionals reflect on racial stereotypes and ethnic diversity in the organization

Abstract

PurposeThe aim of this article is to examine how professionals within Dutch sports media give meaning to racial/ethnic diversity in the organization and reflect on the use of racial stereotypes in sports reporting.Design/methodology/approachTen in-depth interviews with Dutch sports media professionals have been conducted to obtain the data. Respondents had a variety of responsibilities within different media organizations in the Netherlands. The authors used thematic analysis supplemented with insights from critical discourse analysis to examine how sports media professionals give meaning to racial/ethnic diversity and the use of racial/ethnic stereotypes.FindingsThe following main themes emerged from the analysis of the interviews: (1) routines within the production process, (2) reflections on lack of diversity on the work floor and (3) racial/ethnic stereotyping not seen as an issue. Generally, journalists showed paradoxical views on the issue of racial/ethnic diversity within sport media production dismissing it as a non-issue on the one hand while also acknowledging there is a lack of racial diversity within sport media organizations. Results will be placed and discussed in a wider societal and theoretical perspective.Originality/valueBy focussing on the under-researched social group of sport media professionals in relation to meanings given to race and ethnicity in the production process, this research provides new insights into the role of sports media organizations in (re)producing discourses surrounding race/ethnicity in multi-ethnic society and the operation of whiteness in sports media.

Female journalists who have reached the top: perceptions on communication, leadership, and gender bias in the Portuguese press

“…Detailed data presented in 2020 reports that, although women's visibility as reporters and journalists has increased, gender inequality is still evident: women are the focus of only 6% of total news, without any growth of stereotype challenging stories, which amount to only 3% (Macharia, 2020). These inequalities are in fact quite prevalent, which is clear in a broader scenario concerning not only gender, but race and ethnicity, as reported in van Sterkenburg et al .’s (2021) study with Dutch sports media professionals.…”

Is it in the Game? Reflections of Race-Based Stereotypes in EA SPORTS FIFA 22

“…The support of these hypotheses offers strong evidence that athletes with dark skin tones are being portrayed as more physically dominant in the game than athletes with light skin tones. These notions that athletes with dark skin tone are stronger, run faster, jump higher, and overall excel in the physical aspects of sport reflects many of the stereotypes found within sports media (Eastman & Billings, 2001; Maguire, 1988; van Sterkenburg et al, 2021).…”

“…Within the field of sports media, the literature on representations of race and color is rich (Billings, 2004; Buffington & Fraley, 2008). For decades, scholars have worked to understand what sort of race-based stereotypes and narratives exist within several different areas of sports media (Eastman & Billings, 2001; Maguire, 1988; van Sterkenburg et al, 2021). Historically, many of these analyses have focused their attention on television broadcasts and commentary.…”

Representations of race/ethnicity and the nation: A content analysis of televised Polish international football

“…On the production side, there is a general lack of studies that focus on how journalists, commentators, and producers themselves think about and discuss race/ethnicity in the newsroom. Recently, Sterkenburg et al (2021) have shown how sport journalists often do not reflect on their own commentary. In the Polish context, such a study into sport media production could be useful for exploring how sport journalists perceive racial/ethnic stereotypes in reporting, and how the use of stereotypes relates to work routines and newsroom hierarchies.…”

“…Within such a context, commentators need to react instantly to what happens on the pitch and tend to draw on easily accessible hegemonic discourses. Sport media professionals have also generally been found to rarely reflect on the use of these racial/ethnic stereotypes in their reporting or minimize their impact (Bruce, 2004; Sterkenburg et al, 2021).…”