Long‐term cumulative effects of childcare on children's mental development and socioemotional adjustment in a non‐risk sample: the moderating effects of gender

Abstract

We studied the long-term cumulative effects of two common indices of childcare-the total number of hours of non-maternal care and the mean hour-weighted child-to-caregiver ratio per caregiving situation-on mental development and socioemotional adjustment from birth to 4.5 years old in a non-risk middle-class sample of girls and boys after taking into consideration child (gender and sibling status), maternal (education and concepts of child development), and family selection (socioeconomic status [SES] factors. Childcare indices did not differ in girls and boys year by year. Children experienced less non-maternal care in their first year of life, but afterward children encountered more children in their caregiving situations in proportion to the number of caregivers. At age 4.5 years, girls scored higher on cognitive and language measures than boys, and boys exhibited more externalizing problem behaviors than girls. Hours of non-maternal care were not a predictor of mental development or socioemotional adjustment; however, the child-to-caregiver ratio was. For cognitive outcomes, the ratio exerted a positive effect on children from higher SES backgrounds versus no effect on children from average or lower SES backgrounds. For behavioral adjustment outcomes, a higher ratio was associated with fewer behavioral problems in girls and more behavioral problems in boys. Different basic indices of childcare appear to have different long-term cumulative effects for different domains of development in girls and boys.

Who should care for our kids? The effects of infant child care on early child development

“…First, there is a good deal of evidence that boys in non-maternal care are at higher risk than girls in cognitive and behavioral development (Bornstein et al 2006;Zaslow and Hayes 1986;Langlois and Liben 2003). Second, there may be racial or ethnic differences in motherÁchild interactions and/or in substitute care types, so the effects of child care on child development may differ by racial or ethnic groups (Burchinal et al 2000).…”

Ethnische Unterschiede der Wirkung institutioneller U3-Kinderbetreuung

“…Allerdings korrelieren die kognitiven Fähigkeiten von Vierjährigen positiv mit einer hohen Prozessqualität in der Betreuungseinrichtung (Tietze et al 2013). Einige internationale Studien finden ebenfalls keinen Zusammenhang zwischen frühkindlicher Betreuung von unter Dreijährigen und deren kognitiven Fähigkeiten (Driessen 2004;Bornstein et al 2006;Jaffee et al 2011). Andere Studien berichten eine positive Beziehung (z.…”

A Comparative Study of Structural and Process Quality in Center-Based and Family-Based Child Care Services

“…In addition, researchers recognize that many other related factors have to be taken into account (Li-Grining and Coley 2006;Papero 2005;Vandell 2004;Vortruba-Drzal et al 2004). Accordingly, recent research often adopts an ecosystemic approach that considers variables present in various contextual systems, from the most proximal to the most distal (Bigras and Japel 2007;Bigras et al 2004aBigras et al , b, 2008aBornstein et al 2006;Scott-Little et al 2006).…”