Is an Ideal Sense of Humor Gendered? A Cross-National Study

Abstract

To explore lay conceptions of characteristics of an ideal sense of humor as embodied in a known individual, our study examined elicited written narratives by male and female participants from three different countries of origin: United States, Iran, and Turkey. As reported in an earlier previous study with United States-based participants (Crawford and Gressley, 1991), our study also found that the embodiment of an ideal sense of humor was predominantly a male figure. This effect was more pronounced for male than for female participants but did not differ by country. Relative mention of specific humor characteristics differed by participant gender and by country of origin. Whereas all groups mentioned creativity most often as a component of an ideal sense of humor, this attribute was mentioned significantly more often by Americans than by the other two groups; hostility/sarcasm was also mentioned significantly more often by Americans than Turkish participants who mentioned it more often than Iranian participants. Caring was mentioned significantly more often by Americans and Iranians than by Turkish participants. These findings show a shared pattern of humor characteristics by gender but group differences in the relative prominence given to specific humor characteristics. Further work is needed to corroborate the group differences observed and to pinpoint their source.

How Do We Perceive a Humorous Manager? Manager Humor, Impression Management, and Employee Willingness to Work With the Manager

“…Since females tend to respond more emotionally to given events ( Fischer et al, 2018 ), it could explain why females in our study showed a compensating tradeoff between warmth and competence, while men did not. In addition, the humor/gender literature suggests that men and women may react differently to humor communications ( Tosun et al, 2018 ), and the purpose of humor seems to shift between genders ( Chan, 2016 ). Humor is usually regarded as a predominately masculine trait ( Hooper et al, 2016 ); men use humor as a tool to reinforce social order and sustain the status quo .…”

“…We maintain that this is an oversight, predominantly when examining the issue of gender. The ideas that male and female behavior will be interpreted differently were expressed 25 years ago (e.g., Crawford and Gressley, 1991 ) and are still maintained today ( Tosun et al, 2018 ). For example, Cooper K.M.…”

Gender stereotypes depicted in online sexist jokes

“…Wu et al (2016) also find that, compared to women, men tend to use unfriendly and aggressive humour. More recently, Tosun et al (2018) also find that male figures were more likely considered as the ones embodied an "ideal" sense of humour.…”

Perceived related humor in the classroom, student–teacher relationship quality, and engagement: Individual differences in sense of humor among students

“… Note: PRH = perceived related humor, TSRQ = teacher–student relationship quality, ENG = engagement, SH = sense of humor, **p < .01. Control variables: We added two control variables (gender and age) based on the consideration that both are related to a personal sense of humor [ 19 , 56 ] as well as the perceived quality of the relationship between students and teachers [ 35 , 57 ]. Both variables are coded: female (1), male (2), <20 yo (1), 20–25 yo (2), and above 25 yo (3).…”