“…inequalities due to differences in u i are legitimate), while in ( 7) and ( 9) they are treated as circumstances. 1 Counterfactual, y c1 has become the most popular; it was used, e.g., by Rosa Dias (2009), Gignoux (2011), Ferreira andGignoux (2014), Brunori et al (2012), Marrero and Rodríguez (2012), Foguel and Veloso (2014) and Niehues and Peichl (2014). Fleurbaey and Schokkaert (2009) suggest to use y c3 and y c4 .…”