Green revolution has succeeded in increasing Indonesia's rice production, but it also has an impact on decreasing the level of soil fertility, due to the excessive use of chemical fertilizers. Subang Regency is one of the rice production centers in West Java, where some farmers have begun to utilize straw as organic fertilizer as an effort to improve soil fertility, as well as the sustainability of their farming. This study aims to compare the production, farmers' income, and R-C ratio of farmers who use straw compared to those who do not use straw as organic fertilizer, as well as analyzing the factors that influence farmers to utilize straw. The study uses quantitative inquiry, sample was taken by using multi stage cluster sampling. Research was conducted on 228 respondents in Binong, Pusakanegara, and Patokbeusi Sub-District, Subang, West Java. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews. Data were analyzed with descriptive analysis and logistic regression function. The results showed that the level of production, income, and R-C ratio of farmers who return straw is higher than the farmers who do not return. Aside of that, factors that influence farmers' decision to return straw to rice fields are income level and nature of innovation.