A comparative life cycle assessment (LCA) between three different cheese packages (P1: completely polypropylene (PP), P2: tin and polyethylene (PE), and P3: carton and PE) has been carried out for the production, distribution and waste disposal (100% landfill) phase. A package for 1 kg of cheese was selected as the functional unit. SimaPro7 software (PRConsultants, The Netherlands) was used for the LCA study. The EcoIndicator 99 method was selected for comparison of the packages. The comparisons show that the total environmental performance of the cheese package types in order from worst to best is P2, P1, and P3. This conclusion was supported by a sensitivity analysis, which was conducted by using different impact assessment methods.
IntroductionCheese production is a complex system where different reactions take place during the maturation and storage processes. After manufacture, semihard cheese undergoes a maturation process according to the ripening conditions that the cheese is exposed to. This process influences the texture, flavor, and all other chemical and physical properties of a cheese. When a packaging system is used with the objective of extending the shelf-life of the product, the maturation process has to be considered [1]. Since it is a complex system, the selection of a suitable packaging material has an important role in cheese packaging.The packaging materials obtain some properties such as vapor and gas permeability/impermeability, heat and oil impermeability through their operation. Several durability tests are conducted by the manufacturing companies to determine the performance of the packages [2].Cheese packages on the market may be completely composed of plastic or a combination of plastic and carton or plastic and tin. The environmental effects of packaging materials are varied depending on the material used. The potential effects of packaging material on the environment can be determined by conducting a life cycle assessment (LCA) study.LCA is a tool used to assess the environmental impacts of product systems and services, accounting for the emissions produced and resources used during the production, distribution, use, and disposal of a product. LCA has been developed from the analysis of cumulative or embodied energy demand [3]. It was developed rapidly during the 1990's and has reached a certain level of harmonization and standardization. An International Standards Organization (ISO) standard has been developed, as well as several guidelines. LCA studies the environmental aspects and potential impacts throughout a "product" life, i. e., cradle-to-grave, from raw material acquisition through production, use, and disposal [4]. Throughout these stages, the extraction and consumption of resources (including energy) and emissions release into air, water, and soil are identified and quantified. Subsequently, the potential impact contributions of the resource extraction and consumption, as well as environmental releases resulting in several important impacts on the environmental, are asse...