The case of TelessaúdeRS/UFRGS shows that even in the presence of structural limitations, telemedicine is potentially useful to improve the quality of care and streamline the flow between different levels of care.
Resumo Na Atenção Primária à Saúde (APS) acesso e integralidade são fortemente influenciados pela coordenação do cuidado, que por sua vez recebe impacto positivo da articulação de ações de telessaúde para a telerregulação da assistência. Criamos uma metodologia de telerregulação (Projeto RegulaSUS) baseada em protocolos específicos firmemente alicerçados em evidências. A partir de dados do sistema de regulação e do TelessaúdeRS exploramos os efeitos do RegulaSUS na APS e no acesso ao cuidado especializado. A metodologia foi capaz de criar protocolos abrangentes, com expressiva redução média da fila de consultas especializadas de 30% em 360 dias. Reduziu o tempo de espera na marcação de consultas em especialidades clínicas (mediana de 66 dias), mas não em cirúrgicas. Tempos de espera nos casos mantidos em fila variaram de forma inversa, aumentado em especialidades clínicas e diminuindo em cirúrgicas. O uso de teleconsultorias espontâneas aumentou com a exposição dos profissionais ao RegulaSUS. A intervenção tem potencial na integração de sistemas de saúde, principalmente em países de baixa e média renda, e faz com que a telessaúde atue como metasserviço, construindo redes eficientes, qualificadas e equânimes.
Background Primary health care (PHC) delivery in Brazil has improved in the last decades. However, it remains unknown whether the Family Health Strategy teams are meeting the health needs of the population. Objectives To describe the reasons for encounter (RFEs) in PHC in Brazil and to examine variations in RFEs according to sex, age and geographic region. Methods This descriptive study is part of a national cross-sectional study conducted in 2016. The sample was stratified by the number of PHC physicians per geographic region. Physicians who had been working for at least 1 year in the same PHC unit were included. For every participating physician, 12 patients aged ≥18 years who had attended at least two encounters were included. Patients were asked about their RFEs, which were classified according to the International Classification of Primary Care. Results In 6160 encounters, a total of 8046 RFEs were coded. Seven reasons accounted for 50% of all RFEs. There was a high frequency of codes related to test results, medication renewal and preventive medicine. RFEs did not vary significantly by sex or geographic region, but they did by age group (P < 0.001). The rates of prescriptions, requests for investigations and referrals to specialized care were 71.1%, 42.8%, and 21.3%, respectively. Conclusion This novel study opened the ‘black box’ of RFEs in PHC in Brazil. These findings can contribute to redefining the scope of PHC services and reorienting work practices in order to improve the quality of PHC in Brazil.
Our challenge was to structure a telemedicine framework that is capable of expanding access to services and testing while increasing the quality of the services provided. In this report, we describe the development of a telemedicine project in Brazil and its impact on increasing access to specialist consultations, diagnostic testing, and specialized medical advice to physicians. WHO & WHEREIn early By December, 2016, more than 83,000 hotline teleconsultations had been provided, with user satisfaction rates close to 95%. Specialist consultation was rendered unnecessary in 2 out of every 3 cases discussed.The state of Rio Grande do Sul struggles with large waiting lists in various medical specialties. The wait time can in many cases exceed 3 years. We worked with the Rio Grande do Sul State Department of Health to improve the quality of specialist referrals through development of referral protocols and clinical discussion of waitlisted patients. This has been implemented for 13 medical specialties, with protocols developed for 147 health conditions. As a result, the backlog of specialty appointments was reduced from 190,000 to 68,000 in just 2 years (July 2014 to Dec 2016). We had no problem adding specialists because we created a new field of work for them within the project.We have also expanded our portfolio with telediagnosis and tele-education initiatives. Tele-education actions include the provision of health apps (230,000 downloads so far), distance learning (15,000 students), a YouTube channel, (more than 1 million views) and a website where all our services are centralized. In 2013, we added a telespirometry service, which has already provided 13,000 tests using 9 spirometers distributed across the state of Rio Grande do Sul, enough to cover 100% of the state population of 11 million. This alone has sharply reduced wait times for pulmonary medicine consults (See the Supplemental Appendix).Brazil's medical residency programs are expected to encourage residents to use our tools, which are also promoted through contact with coordinators and presentations at national congresses. In our university, all 140 medical students in their final year are required to make at least 2 teleconsultations in the 3 months of internship. LEARNINGThrough this project, we have learned that effective information and communication technologies can be extremely valuable in health care. Telehealth represents the future of primary health care, and there is no way back.
RESUMO Objetivo Avaliar a qualidade da atenção primária à saúde (APS) no Brasil e sua associação com o Programa Mais Médicos (PMM). Métodos Este estudo transversal de abrangência nacional utilizou a ferramenta PCATool-Brasil para avaliar a qualidade da APS a partir da experiência dos usuários vinculados a três categorias de médicos: médicos brasileiros do PMM, médicos cubanos do PMM e médicos brasileiros não vinculados ao PMM. Os seguintes escores foram calculados: Escore Geral da APS, Escore de Acesso e Escore de Longitudinalidade. A associação entre o Escore Geral obtido, a categoria do médico e outras características dos usuários e dos profissionais foi investigada por análise multinível. Resultados O Escore Geral da APS para o Brasil foi 6,78, e o Escore de Longitudinalidade, 7,43. Não houve diferença entre esses escores para as três categorias de médicos. O Escore de Acesso para o Brasil foi de 4,24, havendo diferença pequena, mas significativa (P-valor < 0,001), entre as categorias de médicos: médicos cubanos do PMM com 4,43 (IC: 4,32 a 4,54), médicos brasileiros do PMM com 4,08 (IC: 3,98 a 4,18) e médicos brasileiros não vinculados ao PMM com 4,20 (IC: 4,09 a 4,32). Na análise multinível, idade, estrato socioeconômico, presença de doenças crônicas e o fato de o médico realizar visita domiciliar influenciaram positivamente o Escore Geral. Conclusões O tipo de médico não influenciou o grau de orientação aos atributos da APS (Escore Geral) no Brasil. O PMM associou-se a maiores Escores de Acesso em regiões de maior vulnerabilidade socioeconômica. Com a análise multinível, identificamos que o fortalecimento da APS também pode ser alcançado ao reforçar papéis fundamentais dos médicos que trabalham na APS (como as visitas domiciliares) e aprimorar o acesso das populações de maior vulnerabilidade socioeconômica e de pessoas mais jovens ou sem doenças crônicas.
OBJECTIVE To describe the process of cross-cultural adaptation of the Patient-Doctor Relationship Questionnaire (PDRQ-9), as well as compare the agreement between two different types of application.METHODS This is a cross-sectional study with 133 adult users of a Primary Health Service in Porto Alegre, State of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil. The PDRQ-9 was answered by the participants as a self-administered questionnaire and in an interview. The instrument was also validated by interview, using data from 628 participants of the Mais Médicos Program Evaluation Research, which is a cross-sectional study with a systematic sample of Primary Care Services in all regions of Brazil. We evaluated the semantic, conceptual, and item equivalence, as well as factor analysis and reliability.RESULTS All items presented factor loading > 0.5 in the different methods of application and populations in the factor analysis. We found Cronbach’s alpha of 0.94 in the self-administered method. We found Cronbach’s alpha of 0.95 and 0.94 in the two different samples in the interview application. The use of PDRQ-9 with an interview or self-administered was considered equivalent.CONCLUSIONS The cross-cultural adaptation of the PDRQ-9 in Brazil replicated the factorial structure found in the original study, with high internal consistency. The instrument can be used as a new dimension in the evaluation of the quality of health care in clinical research, in the evaluation of services and public health, in health management, and in professional training. Further studies can evaluate other properties of the instrument, as well as its behavior in different populations and contexts.
In Dec 2020 Brazil became one of the worldwide epicenters of the COVID-19 pandemic with more than 7.2M reported cases. Brazil has a large territory with unequal distribution of healthcare resources including physicians. Resource limitation has been one of the main factors hampering Brazil’s response to the COVID-19 crisis. Telemedicine has been an effective approach for COVID-19 management as it allows to reduce the risk of cross-contamination and provides support to remote rural locations. Here we present the analyses of teleconsultations from a countrywide telemedicine service (TelessáudeRS-UFRGS, TRS), that provides physician-to-physician remote support during the COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil. We performed a descriptive analysis of the teleconsultation incoming calls and a text analysis from the call transcripts. Our findings indicate that TRS teleconsultations in Brazil experienced an exponential increment of 802.% during a period of 6 days, after the first death due to COVID-19 was reported. However, the number of teleconsultations cases decreased over time, despite the number of reported COVID-19 cases continuously increasing. The results also showed that physicians in low-income municipalities, based on GDP per capita, are less likely to consult the telemedicine service despite facing higher rates of COVID-19 cases. The text analysis of call transcripts from medical teleconsultations showed that the main concern of physicians were “asymptomatic” patients. We suggest an immediate reinforcement of telehealth services in the regions of lower income as a strategy to support COVID-19 management.
Resumo O SARS-CoV-2, vírus causador da Covid-19, é o terceiro coronavírus a causar doença grave em humanos e que apresentou disseminação global nas duas últimas décadas. Nesse contexto, diversos departamentos nacionais de saúde pública, entre eles o Ministério da Saúde do Brasil, trouxeram destaque àquilo que era, até então, considerado um serviço de apoio ao sistema de saúde: a telessaúde e a telemedicina. Pretendemos apresentar as ações realizadas por um serviço nacional de telessaúde no Brasil, tanto no suporte aos profissionais de saúde da Atenção Primária à Saúde quanto a pacientes, além de discutir o potencial de reorganizar um sistema de saúde. Estudo de prevalência que sumariza as ações de telemedicina adotadas pelo TelessaúdeRS-UFRGS no período da 9ª à 27ª semana epidemiológica de 2020 para apoio aos serviços de saúde do Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS). Houve aumento de 76,8% da demanda de teleconsultorias telefônicas no período avaliado em comparação com o mesmo período em 2019, sendo 28,8% dessa demanda total decorrente de dúvidas relacionada à Covid-19. A pandemia por Covid-19 demandou rápida resposta com a organização de materiais sobre a doença, uma nova equipe para execução das atividades de telemonitoramento e teleconsultas, além da elaboração de um manual para teleconsultas na Atenção Primária à Saúde.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
334 Leonard St
Brooklyn, NY 11211
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.