Recent cadmium (Cd) regulation in chocolate threatens the sustainability of cacao production in Southwest America. Cadmium contamination in cacao beans has not been assessed at a country level. A nationwide survey was conducted in Ecuador to identify the spatial distribution of Cd in cacao beans, as well as soil and agronomic factors involved. Paired soil and plant samples (pods and leaves) were collected at 560 locations. Information on agronomic practices was obtained through a prepared questionnaire for farmers. Total soil Cd averaged 0.44 mg kg which is typical for young and non-polluted soils. Mean Cd concentration in peeled beans was 0.90 mg kg and 45% of samples exceeded the 0.60 mg kg threshold. Bean Cd hotspots were identified in some areas in seven provinces. Multivariate regression analysis showed that bean Cd concentrations increased with increasing total soil Cd and with decreasing soil pH, oxalate-extractable manganese (Mn) and organic carbon (OC) (R = 0.65), suggesting that Cd solubility in soil mainly affects Cd uptake. Bean Cd concentration decreased a factor of 1.4 as the age of the orchard increased from 4 to 40 years. Bean Cd concentration was inconsistently affected by genotype (CCN-51 vs. Nacional), pruning or application of fertilizers. It is concluded that the relatively larger bean Cd concentrations in Ecuador are related to the high Cd uptake capacity of the plants combined with their cultivation on young soils, instead of Cd depleted weathered soils. Mitigation strategies should consider the application of amendments to modify such soil properties to lower soil Cd availability. There is scope for genetic mitigation strategy to reduce bean Cd, but this needs to be properly investigated.

No abstract

Cadmium concentrations in cacao (Theobroma cacao L.) beans from South America often exceed trade limits. Liming soil is advocated as a remediation option, but amendments cannot be incorporated into the entire root zone without harming the trees. An experiment was set up to identify how Cd uptake varies within the root zone when surface and subsurface soil layers are either limed or not. The experiment used 22-cm-height pots with top and bottom layers using surface and subsurface soil samples from a cacao field. The potted soils were either surface limed or not or fully limed and layers spiked with stable 108 Cd isotope in various combinations to trace the plant Cd provenance. The root distribution was neither affected by liming nor by soil source; 70% of the root biomass was present in the top layer. Plants grown on the fully limed surface soil had 1.7 times lower Cd concentrations in leaves than the unlimed treatments, whereas this concentration was 1.2 times lower when only the top layer was limed (surface soil used in both layers). The isotope dilution data showed that surface soil liming enhanced Cd uptake from the unlimed bottom layer compared with the unlimed soil, suggesting compensating mechanisms. The pots containing surface soil over subsurface soil also showed that compensating effect but, due to lower phytoavailable Cd in the subsurface soil, surface liming still effectively reduced foliar Cd. We conclude that liming might be a feasible mitigation strategy, but its effectiveness is limited when Cd phytoavailability remains untreated in the subsurface layer.

Soil liming to lower cadmium (Cd) bioavailability is challenged in perennial cacao orchards by the low penetration of lime in soils, not reaching deeper roots. Some studies suggest that gypsum (CaSO4) could reduce Cd uptake by enhanced Ca2+:Cd2+ competition at the root surface. A pot experiment was conducted to identify soil conditions affecting gypsum efficacy in cacao plantlets (5‐month‐old CCN‐51). Plants grew for 115 days in soils sampled from six locations with variable cation exchange capacity (CEC, 6–50 cmolc.kg−1) and soil solution Ca2+ (1.3–17 mM). Soils were either mixed or not mixed with a dose equivalent to 4.0 Mg gypsum ha−1. Leaf Cd concentration in plants grown on gypsum applied soils was statistically lower compared to unamended soils in only one of the six soils. The reduction factor of leaf Cd concentrations due to gypsum (RF = control/amended Cd concentration ratio) ranged from 2.32 (high effect) to 0.76 (no effect), and it was positively correlated with the Ca2+ in the solution of the unamended soil (R2 = 0.58) and with increasing CEC (R2 = 0.52), that is, gypsum only reduced Cd bioavailability in high CEC soils, confirming a trend found in earlier publications. Soil solution analyses showed that gypsum application enhanced total dissolved Cd by forming CdSO40 complexes with, in some cases, even enhanced Cd2+ ion activities, likely related to Ca2+‐induced Cd2+ mobilisation. Data suggest that Ca2+ derived from gypsum has counteracting effects on Cd mobilisation and ion competition at the root surface. The former reactions are less pronounced in high CEC soils. More research is needed to unravel gypsum effects on high Ca2+ soils to corroborate our findings. Highlights The effect of soil properties on the efficacy of gypsum to reduce Cd uptake in cacao was studied. Gypsum only reduced Cd uptake in cacao in the soil sample with highest CEC and highest Ca in solution. This finding implies a possible competition between Ca2+ and Cd2+ for root uptake in cacao.

No abstract

Elevated cadmium (Cd) concentrations in cacao (Theobroma cacao L.) beans have concerned chocolate consumers worldwide because of the potential detrimental human health effects. Compost application on the soil surface could modify the labile Cd in soils and yet it could enhance Cd bound to humic and fulvic acids, forming an organo-metallic complex that could reduce the availability of Cd to plants. This study investigated the effect of surface compost applications at two rates, the chemistry and fractionation of Cd at two soil depths, and the relationship of these soil Cd pools with plant uptake. The research was carried out on four Ecuadorian cacao farms. The compost was applied at 6.25 Mg·ha−1 (low) and 12.5 Mg·ha−1 (high) per annum. There was also a control treatment with no compost application. Soil samples were collected at two depths, surface (0–5 cm) and below surface (5–20 cm). Leaf samples and cacao pots were collected from each treatment. Soil Cd was fractionated into five operational pools. Additionally, the Cd-bound to fulvic acids and humic acids in soils were extracted separately. The EDTA-extractable fraction showed the highest concentration of Cd at both depths. Cadmium bound to fulvic acids was higher in compost-applied soils than in the control (p < 0.05) in all farms. Leaf and bean-Cd were negative and significantly correlated with the Cd extracted by EDTA, NaOH, HNO3, and FA-Cd pools. The mobility of Cd in soils cultivated with cacao, based on plant uptake, was strongly associated with the soils’ chemical characteristics, especially pH and SOC. The surface application of organic matter facilitates the redistribution of Cd in soil fractions, mainly in EDTA-, NaOH-, and HNO3-extractable fractions, suggesting a reduction in Cd soil–plant transfer via adsorption or complexation processes. Apparently, the application of high-quality compost, i.e., high FA content, could aid in mitigating Cd contamination in cacao orchards. Experiments on perennial crops merit a longer evaluation time to better assess the changes in plant-Cd.