Tracking the diffusion of industrial symbiosis scholarship using bibliometrics: Comparing across Web of Science, Scopus, and Google Scholar

Abstract

Previous bibliometric analyses of industrial symbiosis (IS) research have focused on a limited body of literature owing to the scope of keyword searches or limitations of library databases. This study seeks to apply bibliometrics to explore broader, epistemological questions, particularly about the structure and geospatial development of IS as a sub-field of industrial ecology. We also evaluate the benefits of using Google Scholar, in addition to the conventional databases Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus, for better understanding academic domains. By using WoS and Scopus, 805 articles on IS that met our criteria were identified, published in 212 journals from 1995 through 2018.On average, the cumulative number of relevant articles grew at an exponential rate of 18% per year-more than double the estimated growth of global scientific output.We observed the largest increases in articles that: (1) model the material and energy flows in IS clusters; (2) propose strategies and ideas for implementing symbiosis; and(3) evaluate the performance of IS networks. By the end of 2018, 54 countries were featured in IS articles retrieved from WoS and Scopus, with China as the single most studied country. The analysis of Google Scholar suggested that it can capture more IS articles than the conventional databases owing to its unique characteristic of searching the entire text of documents rather than solely their metadata as with WoS and Scopus. Google Scholar revealed IS discourse from additional countries and disciplines previously omitted, enabling a more acute view of its patterns of diffusion.

The patient as a prosumer of healthcare: insights from a bibliometric-interpretive review

“…Moreover, Scopus has been argued to represent a comprehensive and relevant source of information for conducting systematic reviews, which yields similar results to other available sources for conducting literature analysis, such as Clarivate Analytics' Web of Science (Vieira and Gomes, 2009). Though Google Scholar has been argued to represent a valuable source for literature reviews (Chertow et al. , 2021), it does not efficiently provide consistent and complete bibliometric data for reviews.…”

Systems Engineering applied in the construction industry to achieve a BREEAM certification

“…It was conducted using databases, mainly Google Scholar and Oria, in addition to relevant papers provided by the university. Recent bibliometric analysis concluded that Google Scholar is able to capture more articles from a greater diversity of sources than other databases (Chertow et al, 2021). The following search keywords were used to find relevant literature:…”

Transition from Parks to Eco-industrial Parks: insights into this necessary and complex transformation

“…O principal objetivo desta pesquisa é, portanto, identificar elementos, oportunidades e barreiras à aplicação da SI para fomentar a transição de parques industriais e mistos em EIP, considerando a realidade do Brasil, visto que o estudo contempla um parque empresarial localizado na região Sul. Chertow et al (2021) e Herzer et al (2020) destacaram que o Brasil possui poucas publicações de relevância internacional no tema da SI e EIP. Chertow et al (2021), em revisão bibliométrica, identificaram apenas 07 artigos científicos de trabalhos realizados no Brasil nas principais bases de dados mundiais.…”