The Macrosociology of Paid Domestic Labor

Abstract

This article poses the question: What explains variation in the proportion of the labor force employed in paid domestic labor? In contrast to an older, modernization-theory-based literature that argued that paid domestic labor declines and ultimately disappears in the course of economic development, the authors note the occupation's recent expansion in southern California and the wide variations among rich, developed countries in the proportion of the female workforce employed in it. The authors argue that a crucial, neglected factor in explaining such geographic variations is the extent of economic inequality. This factor is overlooked not only in the modernization-theory-based literature but also in recent microsociological studies of paid domestic labor, which highlight the ways in which race, ethnicity, and citizenship status are implicated in interactions between employers of domestics and the workers themselves, while ignoring the enduring significance of class in the employer/domestic relationship. By analyzing 1990 census data for the 100 largest metropolitan areas in the United States, the authors show that income inequality (as well as, but independent of, the proportion of the female labor force made up of African Americans and Latinas, the proportion of the female labor force that is foreign born, and maternal labor force participation), is a significant predictor of the proportion of the female labor force employed in domestic labor.

Income Inequality and Household Labor

“…Milkman et al (1998) come down squarely on the side of Jencks et al (1972) and Sassen (1991), succinctly stating, "it is logical to expect that the greater the extent of economic inequality in a community-in other words, the greater the disparity in resources between rich and poor households-the more easily rich households can afford to employ less fortunate persons as domestic servants" (p. 496). Milkman et al (1998) then provide a brief empirical illustration of this idea, taking a sample of US cities and showing a positive correlation in cross-sectional 1990 Census data between household income inequality and the share of female workers employed in private households in domestic service.…”

Les écarts salariaux dans une profession à prédominance féminine: le travail domestique informel et flexible au Portugal

“…Cependant, ce n'est pas seulement une question de sexe. L'approche intersectionnelle montre que l'interaction entre l'origine nationale, sociale et ethnique et la situation vis-à-vis de la migration peut accroître le préjudice subi (Milkman, Reese et Roth, 1998). Les travaux de recherche ont montré que la fixation des salaires dans le travail domestique est loin d'être simple.…”

“…Le fait de travailler dans un domicile privé induit isolement social, invisibilité et défaut de réglementation, ce qui rend ces travailleurs encore plus vulnérables face à l'exploitation (Milkman, Reese et Roth, 1998).…”

"An Ebbing Tide Lowers All Boats": How the Great Recession of 2008 Affected Men and Women in Central and Eastern Europe

“…To může vést k dlouhodobým dopadům na migrační vzorce. Proces migrace žen z chudších zemí do vyspělejších regionů za prací v oblasti péče může být udržován v chodu pouze dostatečně vysokou mírou nerovnosti (Milkman, Reese, Roth 1998;Bettio et al 2012). Potvrzují to i nejnovější migrační data Eurostatu.…”