“…In the 19th century, before the chromosomal theory of inheritance, scientists argued over the role that the nucleus plays in transmission of information to the next generation. Hertwig, Strasburger, von Kolliker, and Weismann, hypothesized that the nucleus is the carrier of hereditary properties (Churchill, 1987;Weismann, 1893), while other contemporaries, most notably the Swiss botanist Carl Nägeli, believed that the heritable agents ignore cellular and sub-cellular boundaries (Nägeli claimed that the hereditary substance is somewhere in the "protoplasm") (Rogers, 2014, pages 136-137). Similarly, Darwin believed in soma-to-germline inheritance of extra-nuclear information (via "gemmules'', reviewed in : Bowler, 2003;Liu, 2008Liu, , 2018.…”