SummaryIn C. elegans nematodes, components of liquid-like germ granules were shown to be required for transgenerational small RNA inheritance. Surprisingly, we show here that mutants with defective germ granules can nevertheless inherit potent small RNA-based silencing responses, but some of the mutants lose this ability after many generations of homozygosity. Animals mutated in pptr-1, which is required for stabilization of P granules in the early embryo, display extraordinarily strong heritable RNAi responses, lasting for tens of generations. Intriguingly, the RNAi capacity of descendants derived from mutants defective in the core germ granule proteins MEG-3 and MEG-4 is determined by the genotype of the ancestors and changes transgenerationally. Further, whether the meg-3/4 mutant alleles were present in the paternal or maternal lineages leads to different transgenerational consequences. Small RNA inheritance, rather than maternal contribution of the germ granules themselves, mediates the transgenerational defects in RNAi of meg-3/4 mutants and their progeny. Accordingly, germ granule defects lead to heritable genome-wide mis-expression of endogenous small RNAs. Upon disruption of germ granules, hrde-1 mutants can inherit RNAi, although HRDE-1 was previously thought to be absolutely required for RNAi inheritance. We propose that germ granules sort and shape the RNA pool, and that small RNA inheritance maintains this activity for multiple generations.

In C. elegans nematodes, components of liquid-like germ granules were shown to be required for transgenerational small RNA inheritance. Surprisingly, we show here that mutants with defective germ granules (pptr-1, meg-3/4, pgl-1) can nevertheless inherit potent small RNA-based silencing responses, but some of the mutants lose this ability after many generations of homozygosity. Animals mutated in pptr-1, which is required for stabilization of P granules in the early embryo, display extremely strong heritable RNAi responses, which last for tens of generations, long after the responses in wild type animals peter out. The phenotype of mutants defective in the core germ granules proteins MEG-3 and MEG-4, depends on the genotype of the ancestors: Mutants that derive from maternal lineages that had functional MEG-3 and MEG-4 proteins exhibit enhanced RNAi inheritance for multiple generations. While functional ancestral meg-3/4 alleles correct, and even potentiates the ability of mutant descendants to inherit RNAi, defects in germ granules functions can be memorized as well; Wild type descendants that derive from lineages of mutants show impaired RNAi inheritance for many (>16) generations, although their germ granules are intact. Importantly, while P granules are maternally deposited, wild type progeny derived from meg-3/4 male mutants also show reduced RNAi inheritance. Unlike germ granules, small RNAs are inherited also from the sperm.Moreover, we find that the transgenerational effects that depend on the ancestral germ granules require the argonaute protein HRDE-1, which carries heritable small RNAs in the germline. Indeed, small RNA sequencing reveals imbalanced levels of many endogenous small RNAs in germ granules mutants. Strikingly, we find that hrde-1;meg-3/4 triple mutants inherit RNAi, although hrde-1 was previously thought to be essential for heritable silencing. We propose that germ granules sort and shape the RNA pool, and that small RNA inheritance memorizes this activity for multiple generations.

Studies using C. elegans nematodes demonstrated that, against the dogma, animals can transmit epigenetic information transgenerationally. While it is now clear that in these worms ancestral RNA interference (RNAi) responses continue to regulate gene expression for many generations, it is still debated whether the primary agent that perpetuates heritable silencing is RNA or chromatin, and whether the information is communicated to the next generation inside or outside of the nucleus. Here we take advantage of the tractability of gene-specific double stranded RNA-induced heritable silencing to answer these questions. We demonstrate that RNAi can be inherited independently of any changes to the chromatin or any other nuclear factors via mothers that are genetically engineered to transmit only their ooplasm but not the oocytes' nuclei to the next generation. Nucleus-independent RNA inheritance depends on ZNFX-1, an RNA-binding germ granule resident protein. We find that upon manipulation of normal germ granules functions (in pptr-1 mutants) nucleus-independent RNA inheritance becomes stronger, and can occur even in znfx-1 mutants. Utilizing RNA sequencing, chimeric worms, and sequence polymorphism between different C. elegans isolates, we identify endogenous small RNAs which, similarly to exogenous siRNAs, are inherited in a nucleus-independent manner. From an historical perspective, nucleus-independent inheritance of small RNAs might be regarded as partial vindication of discredited cytoplasmic inheritance theories from the 19th century, such as Darwin's "pangenesis" theory.