“…The typical four XPS peaks of Tb 3+ at 145.23, 147.93, 150.83, and 154.63 eV in Tb 2 O 3 can be found accordingly in the XPS spectrum of Tb 4 O 7 at 146.03, 148.38, 151.03, and 153.83 eV, respectively. However, the peaks at 157.28 and 164.48 eV in Tb 4 O 7 , obviously originated from Tb 4+ , cannot be seen in Tb 2 O 3 , but they correspond very well with the XPS peaks at 157.0 and 164.0 eV in the annealed ScOOH:Tb, i.e., Sc 2 O 3 :Tb (Figure d). This straightforwardly suggests that the oxidation reaction from Tb 3+ to Tb 4+ has happened during the annealing process of ScOOH:Tb, which has made us believe that the partial oxidation of Tb 3+ and the corresponding microenvironmental changes after thermal annealing is responsible for the dramatically weakened luminescence emission of Tb 3+ .…”