Abstract:This study investigates the notion of talent in the tourism and hospitality (TH) industry, proposing a comprehensive talent management (TM) model that is specific to this industry. This study primarily explores the notion of talent, TM, and the importance of these in the industry. A mixed method approach (qualitative and quantitative) was used to fulfill the research objectives. Qualitative content analysis was used to address interview responses from a panel of experts and a survey method was applied to colle… Show more
“…In the business management literature, there is no unanimous definition of talent exists (Thunnissen et al, 2013a , p.1754; Thunnissen et al, 2013b , p.327; McDonnell et al, 2017 , p.109; Golubovskaya et al, 2019 , p.4109; Harsch and Festing, 2020 , p.45). When firms’ perceptions on the meaning and scope of talent are examined, it is observed that their considerations on this issue are shaped and varied according to their own organizational dynamics, inherently, this situation makes it difficult to develop a de facto definition (Iles et al, 2010 , p.180; Tansley, 2011 , p.266; Latukha, 2015 , p.1061; Chung and D’Annunzio-Green, 2018 , p.104; Bagheri et al, 2020 , p.88). Yet, there are some important attempts regarding to the characterization of the talent phenomenon (see Table 2 in Appendix 1 ).…”
Section: Talent Management: Existing Concepts and Debatesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Efforts to create a general definition of talent management will be futile, because each business creates the scope and meaning of talent according to its own dynamics, and naturally their understanding and approach to talent management also differ. As a result of this fact, trying to form common expressions in an area where subjectivity is so intense can be considered as an almost impossible action (Burbach and Royle, 2010 , p.415; McDonnell et al, 2011 , p.178; Jones et al, 2012 , p.402; Pandita and Ray, 2018 , p.187; Bagheri et al, 2020 , p.88). Nevertheless, there are important attempts of academic researchers related with the definition of talent management (see Table 3 in Appendix 2 ), which can be sufficiently suited to the academic need to stimulate theory development while reflecting the interests of practitioners (Garrow and Hirsh, 2008 , p.390; Thunnissen et al, 2013a , p.1749–1750; Cappelli and Keller, 2014 , p.307; Tafti et al, 2017 , p.16).…”
Section: Talent Management: Existing Concepts and Debatesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“… Avedon and Scholes ( 2010 : 75) Talent alludes to significant individuals and groups with the key competencies that facilitate to reach short and long-term objectives of a company. Bagheri et al ( 2020 : 89) Talent refers to three distinct logic: a) capabilities and unique contributions of an individual; b) a significant employee; c) a definite and featured group in a company. Beechler and Woodward ( 2009 : 274); McDonnell et al ( 2011 :178) Talent is the total output of an employee’s KSAs, capabilities and his/her ability to learn and develop.…”
Section: Appendixmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…These are; what the talent is, who is considered to be talent and what does talent management mean. Answering these questions will enable organizations to perceive the components of the system they want to establish on the basis of talent and to shape their procedures and processes accordingly (Bagheri et al, 2020 , p.88). More specifically, according to Tansley ( 2011 ), a working definition of talent and talent management is necessary for sound talent management policies and practices shared in the organization, and structuring these definitions is vital for talent development professionals to be able to design and plan talent oriented training and development programs.…”
Talent management (TM) is referred as a young and developing field and it is claimed to be require more contribution from the different industry and country perspectives. Because of the highly dynamic and competitive nature of the container shipping industry, possession of valuable and unique human capital assets is evaluated as a substantial necessity to achieve business objectives and sustained competitive advantage by container shipping companies. Accordingly, TM is considered to be an essential factor contributing the accomplishment of these goals and the successful implementation of corporate strategy. Therefore, this study aims to contribute the development of TM field by investigating and evaluating TM related concepts and debates in Turkish container shipping industry. Through this extent, a combined method of content analysis with in-depth interview, has been organized to analyse TM oriented subjects in container shipping industry.
“…In the business management literature, there is no unanimous definition of talent exists (Thunnissen et al, 2013a , p.1754; Thunnissen et al, 2013b , p.327; McDonnell et al, 2017 , p.109; Golubovskaya et al, 2019 , p.4109; Harsch and Festing, 2020 , p.45). When firms’ perceptions on the meaning and scope of talent are examined, it is observed that their considerations on this issue are shaped and varied according to their own organizational dynamics, inherently, this situation makes it difficult to develop a de facto definition (Iles et al, 2010 , p.180; Tansley, 2011 , p.266; Latukha, 2015 , p.1061; Chung and D’Annunzio-Green, 2018 , p.104; Bagheri et al, 2020 , p.88). Yet, there are some important attempts regarding to the characterization of the talent phenomenon (see Table 2 in Appendix 1 ).…”
Section: Talent Management: Existing Concepts and Debatesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Efforts to create a general definition of talent management will be futile, because each business creates the scope and meaning of talent according to its own dynamics, and naturally their understanding and approach to talent management also differ. As a result of this fact, trying to form common expressions in an area where subjectivity is so intense can be considered as an almost impossible action (Burbach and Royle, 2010 , p.415; McDonnell et al, 2011 , p.178; Jones et al, 2012 , p.402; Pandita and Ray, 2018 , p.187; Bagheri et al, 2020 , p.88). Nevertheless, there are important attempts of academic researchers related with the definition of talent management (see Table 3 in Appendix 2 ), which can be sufficiently suited to the academic need to stimulate theory development while reflecting the interests of practitioners (Garrow and Hirsh, 2008 , p.390; Thunnissen et al, 2013a , p.1749–1750; Cappelli and Keller, 2014 , p.307; Tafti et al, 2017 , p.16).…”
Section: Talent Management: Existing Concepts and Debatesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“… Avedon and Scholes ( 2010 : 75) Talent alludes to significant individuals and groups with the key competencies that facilitate to reach short and long-term objectives of a company. Bagheri et al ( 2020 : 89) Talent refers to three distinct logic: a) capabilities and unique contributions of an individual; b) a significant employee; c) a definite and featured group in a company. Beechler and Woodward ( 2009 : 274); McDonnell et al ( 2011 :178) Talent is the total output of an employee’s KSAs, capabilities and his/her ability to learn and develop.…”
Section: Appendixmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…These are; what the talent is, who is considered to be talent and what does talent management mean. Answering these questions will enable organizations to perceive the components of the system they want to establish on the basis of talent and to shape their procedures and processes accordingly (Bagheri et al, 2020 , p.88). More specifically, according to Tansley ( 2011 ), a working definition of talent and talent management is necessary for sound talent management policies and practices shared in the organization, and structuring these definitions is vital for talent development professionals to be able to design and plan talent oriented training and development programs.…”
Talent management (TM) is referred as a young and developing field and it is claimed to be require more contribution from the different industry and country perspectives. Because of the highly dynamic and competitive nature of the container shipping industry, possession of valuable and unique human capital assets is evaluated as a substantial necessity to achieve business objectives and sustained competitive advantage by container shipping companies. Accordingly, TM is considered to be an essential factor contributing the accomplishment of these goals and the successful implementation of corporate strategy. Therefore, this study aims to contribute the development of TM field by investigating and evaluating TM related concepts and debates in Turkish container shipping industry. Through this extent, a combined method of content analysis with in-depth interview, has been organized to analyse TM oriented subjects in container shipping industry.
“…As a short-term solution, some have employed migrant labour; however, this impacts upon organisational sustainability (Marinakou and Giousmpasoglou, 2019). It has therefore been suggested that the sectors need to invest in nurturing and managing talent, which will strengthen their image as an employer of choice to overcome key challenges such as service inefficiency and labour deficits (Bagheri et al , 2020).…”
Purpose
This study aims to provide a systematic literature review (SLR) of extant research on talent management (TM) in hospitality and tourism (H&T). The objectives are first, to offer an empirical mapping analysis of TM research in H&T; second, to identify and discuss key research topics; and third, to recommend avenues for future research.
Design/methodology/approach
The authors conducted a SLR of TM literature in the context of H&T by analysing peer-reviewed papers published between January 2000 and October 2020. Following the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis process, three independent coders undertook a content analysis of 74 papers for the SLR.
Findings
The authors found that TM in H&T offers contextualised evidence consistent on five key research topics: TM practices; conceptualisation of talent and TM; TM antecedents and outcomes; key TM stakeholders; and talent education and graduate careers. The analysis indicated that most studies are qualitative, focussed on Europe and North America and that primarily examine hotels. The small number of TM studies in H&T along with the lack of strong theoretical groundings show that the field is at the early stages of the growing stage, yet the sharp increase demonstrates an exponential growth in interest.
Practical implications
This study highlights the importance of TM and indicates that businesses in the sector need to reconsider the definition of talent, their approaches to TM and the bundling of TM practices to improve their effectiveness. It also calls for partnerships among the industry’s key stakeholders and a revisiting of agendas for educators.
Originality/value
To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study that offers a holistic examination of research on a wide range of TM topics within various H&T sectors over the past 20 years. It clarifies the conceptualisation of talent and TM in this field and provides insights, as well as context-specific evidence on the management of H&T talent. This study is the first to argue that the research stream is moving towards a growth stage and offers recommendations on advancing the field.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.