Sympathy and Social Order

Abstract

Social order is possible only if individuals forgo the narrow pursuit of self-interest for the greater good. For over a century, social scientists have argued that sympathy mitigates self-interest and recent empirical work supports this claim. Much less is known about why actors experience sympathy in the first place, particularly in fleeting interactions with strangers, where cooperation is especially uncertain. We argue that perceived interdependence increases sympathy towards strangers. Results from our first study, a vignette experiment, support this claim and suggests a situational solution to social dilemmas. Meanwhile, previous work points to two strong individual-level predictors of cooperation: generalized trust and social values. In Study Two we address the intersection of situational and individual-level explanations to ask: does situational sympathy mediate these individual-level predictors of cooperation? Results from the second study, a laboratory experiment, support our hypotheses that sympathy mediates the generalized trust-cooperation link and the relationship between social values and cooperation. The paper concludes with a discussion of limitations of the present work and directions for future research.

White female undergraduates’ perceptions of Black pregnant adolescents: Does control over pregnancy matter?

“…Perceived trustworthiness of the pregnant adolescent was assessed with three items adapted from Irwin, McGrimmon, and Simpson (2008): “She can be trusted,” “She will take advantage of others if she has the chance” (reverse scored), and “She will try to act responsibly in the future.” Items were rated on a 7-point scale (1 = strongly disagree , 7 = strongly agree ). Responses were averaged such that higher scores reflected greater perceived worthiness of trust.…”

“…Perceived trustworthiness of the pregnant adolescent was assessed with three items adapted from Irwin, McGrimmon, and Simpson (2008): "She can be trusted," "She will take advantage of This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.…”

Social emotional ability development (SEAD): An integrated model of practical emotion-based competencies

“…The dimensions that define the construct of social integration are foundational to social intelligence (Rahim, 2014 ; Srivastava & Das, 2016 ). Sympathetic response tends to facilitate immediate social cooperation and empathetic interaction tends to facilitate improved long-term social engagement; both sympathetic and empathetic responses form the basis for most social interaction and prosocial behavior (Decety & Michalska, 2010 ; Irwin et al, 2008 ; Keltner, et al, 2016 ; Zaki & Ochsner, 2016 ). Improved social engagement is an important predictor of well-being, life satisfaction, and happiness (Baumeister et al, 2013 ; Lambert et al, 2010 ; Rohrer et al, 2018 ).…”

Harmony of Social Order in Preventing Radicalism

“…Several studies in the counseling field support these findings. Social order will be achieved if each member of society can have a great spirit for social interests [54]- [56].…”