Subjective Quality of Life: Its Relationship with Clinician-Rated and Patient-Rated Psychopathology

Abstract

Background: The study compared clinician-rated and patient-rated psychopathology and analysed their relationship with subjective quality of life (QoL) in a sample of patients with a wide range of psychiatric conditions attending a community-based mental health service. Methods: In the context of the South-Verona Outcome Project (SVOP), 139 patients were assessed for both clinician-rated and self-rated psychopathology (by using respectively the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale and the revised version of the Symptom Checklist 90), and asked to report on their subjective quality of life (by using the Lancashire Quality of Life Profile). In order to explore the associations between psychopathology and subjective QoL bivariate and multivariate analyses were performed. Results: BPRS and SCL-90-R were poorly correlated, both in their total scores and in their various dimension scores. BPRS showed only a modest negative correlation with LQL, which, in contrast, was highly negatively correlated with SCL-90-R. Regression analyses showed that patient-rated psychopathology was the strongest predictor of subjective quality of life, with self-rated depressive symptoms and self-reported paranoid ideation having the highest predictive power. Conclusions: Self-reported psychological distress is more important than clinician-rated symptom severity in predicting subjective QoL. In order to improve QoL, psychiatric treatment should focus not only on simple reduction of symptoms but also on patients’ subjective psychological distress.

Persistent Psychological Distress in Patients Treated for Endocrine Disease

“…In clinical endocrinology, there is often the tendency to rely exclusively on ‘hard data’, preferably expressed in the dimensional numbers of laboratory measurements, excluding soft information, such as disability and well- being. This soft information can now, however, be reliably assessed [38, 39]. The evidence that has accumulated with growth hormone deficiency in adult patients [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 40]is an example of the need for multidimensional assessment of treatment effects, encompassing psychosocial parameters.…”

Reasons for Quitting Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitor Therapy: Paradoxical Psychological Side Effects and Patient Satisfaction

“…We undertook this study to try to unravel the paradox of why patients would want to discontinue treatment that was successfully addressing their symptoms. We suspected that psychological side effects – as distinct from physical side effects – may affect patients’ quality of life [6, 7], and that this may be one reason for patients’ dissatisfaction with medication.…”

“…Subjective response has been suggested as a predictor of outcome in pharmacotherapy for schizophrenia [16, 17, 18, 19], and there may be similar relationships between subjective experience, adherence and outcome in pharmacotherapy for depression. Since patients’ report of psychological distress has recently been shown to affect quality of life more than an objective measure of symptom severity [6], it follows that increased psychological distress associated with a medication may affect adherence regardless of symptomatic improvement. The primary goal of this study was to document the existence of psychological side effects associated with SSRIs taken for depression and their effect on patients’ decisions to stop treatment.…”

Navigating Health Sources on the Internet: A Mixed-Methods Examination of Online Consumer Reviews and Expert Text on Psychotropic Drugs

“…Through taking the patient's treatment or "medication history," the clinician embarks on an interpretive process of meaning-making that may or may not remotely reflect the true nature and impact of the drug as experienced by the user (Cohen, 2003). This is partially empirically demonstrated by studies finding poor correlation between clinician-rated and patientrated psychopathology measures (Lasalvia, Ruggeri, & Santolini, 2002). Clinician-rated psychopathology is also poorly correlated, while patient-rated psychopathology is moderately to highly correlated, with subjective quality of life.…”