Struggles for moral value and the reproduction of gendered and racialised hierarchies in online discussions of violence

Abstract

The article examines online discussions in Finland that focus on violence committed by Finnish women, on one hand, and non-white migrant men, on the other. Drawing on the perspective of sociology of value, the article illustrates how these discussions function as sites of struggles over moral worth in a contemporary context characterised by crises of both male and white hegemony. The authors suggest that, through the discussions, these current crises are projected on migrant men and certain groups of women, who thereby become construed as morally reprehensible. The analysis sheds light on processes of (re-)legitimating the moral virtue historically attached to both masculinity and whiteness, and thereby shows how gendered and racialised hierarchies are reproduced in the context of meaning-making around the issue of violence. Also discussed is how these dynamics and the process of reproduction via discourse draw upon historically recurring meanings and evaluations while simultaneously tailored to contemporary circumstances. The tailoring is performed via explicit reference to the value of gender equality, which serves a dual function: re-inscribing moral value in white masculinity while excluding from the circuits of value both racialised masculinities and Finnish women portrayed as doing gender and whiteness in the ‘wrong’ way. These processes give the discussants room for justifying hate and violent exclusion of such women and migrant men while also muting any dissenting voices attempting to resist circulation of the derogatory meanings.

Wounded men of feminism: Exploring regimes of male victimhood in the Spanish manosphere

“…In this context, polarised feminist and antifeminist positions are growing between the Spanish youth, and victimhood occupies a central position in the digital social debate on what has become a struggle for moral value (Venäläinen and Virkki, 2019: 1377). We have explained how victimhood, mobilised through thick affective digital mediated practices, is highly functional for men in the manosphere, as victimhood positions enable them to restore their masculine rational authority, inasmuch as they have the cognitive capacity – which women do not have – to see through feminist lies and gynocentrism thanks to the Red Pill ideology.…”

Expression of masculine identities on Facebook and TikTok: The case of De Machos a Hombres and Voices of Brotherhood

“…En investigaciones más recientes desde este campo de interacción, destaca el estudio de las estructuras de relación en lo virtual que surgen a partir del ejercicio hegemónico de lo masculino (Trott, 2022;Venäläinen & Virkki, 2019) y las construcciones discursivas en torno al ser hombre que tienen lugar en medios sociodigitales (García-Gómez, 2020;White, 2019).…”

Moralitas Kebaikan dan Kesalehan di Seputar Tubuh dan Pakaian dalam Ruang Media Sosial

“…Studi mengenai moralitas yang dihubungkan dengan praktik media sosial dilakukan oleh Venäläinen dan Virki (Venäläinen & Virkki, 2019). Kedua peneliti ini mengkaji percakapan di media daring mengenai kekerasan yang dilakukan oleh perempuan Finlandia dan migran laki-laki non kulit putih.…”