So often, researchers pursue theoretical approaches with little apparent recognition of the work that has been done before. This seems to be the case in 'A theory for flame extinction based upon flame temperature', by Quintiere and Rangwala [1] recently published in Fire and Materials. The concept of an extinction criteria based upon flame temperature can be traced back nearly a century to the work of Burgess and Wheeler [2]. They recognized that at the lower flammable limit (LFL), the adiabatic flame temperature (AFT) is about 1600 K for a wide range of hydrocarbons. Lower temperatures are applicable for gases like hydrogen, carbon monoxide, and acetylene for example. The generality of this finding was increased by the work of White Simmons and Wolfhard [7] first and Ishizuka and Tsuji [8] later showed that the concept was also useful for defining the extent of dilution of a diffusion flame needed to extinguish the flame (oxygen index). They found that the AFT evaluated for a stoichiometric mixture of the fuel gas and the diluted oxygen stream was approximately the same as for the LFL AFTs found for premixed systems.Roberts and Quince [9] examined pool fire extinction as a heat loss process where heat transfer back to the fuel surface dominates the heat extraction to cause extinction. Building on this work Rasbash [10][11][12][13] [18,19] examined piloted ignition within the context of firepoint theory. Beyler used firepoint theory in the prediction of ignition of a hot gas layer in a room fire [20] and in predicting fire suppression [21]. Ewing et al.