Signs of Masculinism in an 'Uneasy' Place: Advertising for 'Big Brothers'

Abstract

Big Brothers' is an international, philanthropic fraternal organisation dedicated, in its own words, 'to match boys seven to seventeen from lone-parent female families with mature male role models over eighteen … toward contributing to the healthy development of these children'. A primary objective of this 90 year-old institution is thus to instil a masculine culture and nurture a masculine identity in male children by providing an adult male presence, 3-4 hours a week, in the lives of boys without a male role model. This article asks, which kinds of masculine identities are promoted as acceptable and why? Drawing upon the geographies of feminism, masculinity, and advertising, the article presents a socio-semiotic analysis of the format, content and signs employed by 'Big Brothers' of Canada and the USA in their recruitment campaigns. Using printed promotional material spanning the institute's history, as well as an interview with the Marketing Director of a recent Big Brother recruitment campaign, the slogans, icons, and gender-myths used to represent males and same-sex friendships in the symbolic spaces of their advertisements are critiqued. Results exemplify the instability of the 'masculine gaze' and suggest that the discourse of patriarchal masculinity situates the Big Brothers institute itself in an 'uneasy' place, one where the masculine gender-myths may be collapsing but are nevertheless evoked to ensure volunteers and society at large that a 'legitimate' form of homosocial masculinity prevails, one that does not transgress 'out of bounds' and into the 'homosexual'.

Gender and Management: New Directions in Research and Continuing Patterns in Practice

“…Marshall, 1984). Moreover, organizations are dominated by masculine values and behaviour (Hopkins, 2000;Jones, 2000;Kimmel, 2004). Gendered processes between the centre and margins.…”

Walter Benjamin’s Dionysian Adventures on Google Earth

“…For all of these Apollonian elements can topologically flip over into Dionysian confusion and anxiety (see Kingsbury, 2007). Our claim here is that Google Earth can become a reversal of Bentham's panopticon (see Doel and Clarke, 1999; see also Gray, 2003;Hopkins, 2000;Koskela, 2003). On Google Earth, instead of the prisoners feeling anxious because they are not sure when they are being observed by the guards in the main control tower, it is also possible for the guards to feel anxious because they cannot see the prisoners.…”

Senior careers in retailing

“…Furthermore, Liff and Cameron (1997) report that men's exclusionary behaviour includes their tendency to share information predominantly with other men, recruit in their own image, ostracise and undermine women and generally act to perpetuate ways of working and forms of interaction with which they feel comfortable. So one explanation for women's under representation at senior management levels is that organisational cultures are dominated by traditionally masculine values and behaviour (Hopkins, 2000;Jones, 2000;Kimmel, 2004).…”