Walter Benjamin’s Dionysian Adventures on Google Earth

Abstract

a b s t r a c tThis paper argues, following Friedrich Nietzsche, that recent evaluations of Google Earth uncritically privilege the product's Apollonian determinations at the expense of its Dionysian uncertainties. Specifically, when we understand Google Earth as a virtual globe composed of surveyed panoramas, sober rationalization, dystopic control, and transparent order -or, even, as a tool for participation and empowermentwe undersell its capacities as an alluring digital peep-box, an uncertain orb spangled with vertiginous paranoia, frenzied navigation, jubilatory dissolution, and intoxicating giddiness. We argue that the former interpretations not only risk foreclosing our theorizations about how Google Earth is actually used in various ways and different contexts, they also reproduce a one-dimensional and conservative reading of technology that can be traced back (at least) to the writings of Theodor Adorno. By drawing on the work of Walter Benjamin (Adorno's critic and pen pal for more than a decade) we aim to 'go beyond Apollo and Adorno' by illustrating the extent to which Apollonian order and Dionysian love makes Google Earth go round. To do this, we examine Google Earth as a ''digital peep-box" with an online collective that revels in its ''Spot the Black Helicopter" competitions; illuminated profanities; alien and giant insect invaders; naked sunbathers; and crashed transport planes in Darfur.

The Spectacle 2.0: Reading Debord in the Context of Digital Capitalism

“…Such Big Data visualizations and systems seek to produce a world in their own image rather than simply interpret an existing one (Kitchin et al 2015). In their leveraging of massive interlinked data sets, they offer a disembodied, apparently omniscient god's eye view of that world Kingsbury and Jones, 2009). While this desire and its limitations have precedents, what is new are the types of data being leveraged and the scales at which these systems operate.…”

Data Derives: Confronting Digital Geographic Information as Spectacle

“…Such Big Data visualizations and systems seek to produce a world in their own image rather than simply interpret an existing one (Kitchin et al 2015). In their leveraging of massive interlinked data sets, they offer a disembodied, apparently omniscient god's eye view of that world (Haraway 1991;Kingsbury and Jones, 2009). While this desire and its limitations have precedents, what is new are the types of data being leveraged and the scales at which these systems operate.…”

The maintenance of urban circulation: An operational logic of infrastructural control

“…During TV transmissions, the relay between studios and the COR draws on satellite imagery and bird's eye views-on ways of seeing from above, intuitively stressing the possibility of an all--round understanding of the city. This viewpoint frames the relationship between the COR and the public eye, an Apollonian gaze which, in the context of smart digital technologies, instils an illusion of total control (Cosgrove, 2003; see also Kingsbury and Jones, 2009). …”