Revisiting Role Theory: Roles and the Problem of the Self

Abstract

This paper looks at some of the major texts in the history of role theory. The question that is asked is whether any of these works have been able to theorize the self adequately. It is suggested that neither Parsons nor Merton has any place for the self in their respective theories. While Goffman does make a space for the self, it is only a negative space. Even ethnomethodological theory cannot imagine a role player capable of self-expression. It is argued that a solution to the problem of how to conceive of self and role can be developed from some ideas present in the work of the philosopher Lawrence Blum. The concept of self as identity that can be extracted from his work can allow social theory to imagine actors who are simultaneously expressing their selves and fulfilling their roles. Affinities between this idea and some key concepts in theories of both (Alan) Blum and Peter McHugh and Charles Taylor are suggested.

The role of the multi-unit manager within the strategy and structure relationship; evidence from the unexpected

“…This highlights the second problem, that of the greater involvement of the self in role behaviour. The self in role is currently an issue which role theory is wrestling with (Raffel, 1999). In this light it is possible to suggest that 'interpretation of accountability' may be an intervening variable between the assessment of a problem and the communication behaviour that ensues.…”

O contributo do treinador profissional para a regulação psicológica e emocional do futebolista

“…The quality of coach intervention in the training depends on the social and cultural context, personal experiences, personal philosophy and profissional practice 34 . Their decisions can be based both on social and personal needs 35 . The influence of the coach's behavior on self-perception, motivation and athlete's performance is mediated in part by the player's evaluation about coach's behavior 36 .…”

Coaching, caring and the politics of touch: a visual exploration

“…Jones et al (ibid. ), borrowing from the work of Blum (1994), interpreted such practice as immersion of self-inrole, where the role becomes something intrinsically worth doing for the individual; an activity which is 'endowed in rightness' for him or her (Raffel, 1998). Noddings (2003: 14) extended this notion by relocating it away from assumed simple altruism.…”