Resistant exit

Kirkpatrick, Jennet

doi:10.1057/s41296-018-0252-1

Cited by 8 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 40 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Walking away creates a vision that is "quite incredible" (336). One way to prompt further discussion on this point is to raise the concept of a "noisy exit" or a "spectacular exit" (Kirkpatrick 2019). In this case, the exit itself is used to draw public attention to injustice or problem.…”

Section: Dissentmentioning

confidence: 99%

Literary Devices: Teaching Social Contract Theory with A Short Story

Kirkpatrick

2021

Journal of Political Science Education

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Teaching the social contract tradition to students can be frustrating. Works by Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau may seem arcane, abstract, or irrelevant to students. Yet, it is important for students to think about what processes or mechanisms would make consent and dissent legitimate. To address this problem, this paper explains how to use a short story, "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas," to examine the procedures of obtaining consent and of engaging in dissent. This paper includes: a plot summary, two paths for integrating "Omelas" into syllabi, and a number of practical tools to use in the classroom, including discussion questions, learning objectives, and a classroom activity. After reading it, you should be able to decide if "Omelas" would be a good addition to your syllabus and, if so, how to use it in your classroom.

show abstract

Section: Dissentmentioning

confidence: 99%

Literary Devices: Teaching Social Contract Theory with A Short Story

Kirkpatrick

2021

Journal of Political Science Education

Self Cite

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Sometimes, we not only sanction or exit; we also signal why we are upset in hopes of correction and restitution. Indeed, as Kirkpatrick (, ) argues, noisy exit can itself help to influence politics, by disrupting, interrupting, and even unseating those in power (see also Dowding and John and Laver ).…”

Section: Standard Accounts Of Exit Voice and Loyalty And Their Limitsmentioning

confidence: 99%

Discursive Exit

Montanaro

2019

American J Political Sci

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Some women did not participate in the Women's March, rejecting its claims of unity and solidarity because white women mobilize only in their self-interest. This is a form of exit with three features: (1) rejecting a political claim; (2) providing reasons to the power wielder and the broader public; and (3) demanding accountability both as sanction and as deliberation, which requires a discussion about the claim-in this case, the meaning of the group and the terms on which it understands itself. This combination of exit, voice, and deliberative accountability might accurately be called "discursive exit." Discursive exit addresses conceptual and normative limitations of standard accounts of exit, voice, and loyalty, in particular, when exit and voice are imperfect-because exit can be seen as disapproval of an entire cause-and morally problematic-because voice "from within" implies that cause trumps disagreement, leaving people morally complicit in an unwelcome exercise of power.

show abstract

“…Drugi oblik je "izlazak uz otpor" (engl. resistant exit) gde sam čin odlaska predstavlja svojevrstan oblik protesta, izaziva nosioce vlasti i remeti politički status quo (Kirkpatrick, 2018).…”

Section: Politički Aktivizamunclassified

'Walking - not to walk away!': Activism and emigration from the perspective of the protestors Against dictatorship

Petrović¹

2018

CM: Commun Media

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Sažetak: Namera ovog rada je da ispita karakteristike odnosa između političkog aktivizma i planova za emigraciju među učesnicima protesta Protiv diktature. Anketno istraživanje učesnika protesta je sprovedeno u tri grada -Beogradu, Nišu i Subotici (N=175), tokom proleća 2017. godine. U radu se polazi od teorijskog modela "izlazakglas" (exit-voice) koji je razvio ekonomista Albert Hiršman (1970). Primenjen u političkom kontekstu, ovaj model dovodi u vezu politički aktivizam i planove za iseljenje na takav način da je, ukoliko postoji prostor za javno iskazivanje nezadovoljstva, sklonost emigraciji manja. S druge strane, u slučaju visokog stepena nezadovoljstva društvenim prilikama i nemogućnosti da se kroz dostupne mehanizme političke participacije na njih utiče, jedan deo građana će odlučiti da se odseli. Nalazi istraživanja pokazuju da su učesnici protesta Protiv diktature politički aktivniji u odnosu na opštu populaciju. Oni češće potpisuju peticije, protestuju, štrajkuju, kontaktiraju predstavnike vlasti i doniraju novac za različite svrhe. Drugim rečima, učesnici protesta čine samo jezgro aktivnog građanstva u Srbiji. Ipak, ni razmišljanja o emigraciji im nisu strana. Većina ispitanika je tu opciju razmatrala a iseljenju su posebno skloni mladi, studenti i radno aktivni. S obzirom na važnost postojanja aktivnog građanstva za razvoj demokratije, visoka sklonost emigraciji učesnika protesta Protiv diktature je nešto što zabrinjava. Iako se fleksibilniji oblici političkog aktivizma (učešće u protestima, okupaciji javnih prostora, štrajkovima itd.), suprotno očekivanjima, nisu pokazali statistički značajno povezanim sa planovima za emigraciju, aktivni angažman kroz političke organizacije izdvojio se kao činilac koji smanjuje šanse preseljenja u drugu zemlju, što delimično potvrđuje pretpostavke izvedene na osnovu Hiršmanovog modela. Ključne reči: politički aktivizam, emigracija, protest Protiv diktature, Srbija 1 Jedna od poruka koja se mogla videti u toku protesta. 2 Ovaj rad je nastao u okviru projekta "Izazovi nove društvene integracije u Srbiji: koncepti i akteri" (ev. broj 179035) koji finansira Ministarstvo prosvete, nauke i tehnološkog razvoja Republike Srbije. 3 Kontakt sa autorkom: vjelisaveta@gmail.com. ORIGINALNI NAUČNI RAD Primljeno: 16.11.2018. Prihvaćeno za objavljivanje: 20.12.2018. "Šetam da ne emigriram!": aktivizam i emigracija iz perspektive učesnika protesta Protiv diktature Jelisaveta Petrović CM : Communication and Media XIII(44) 35-56 © 2018 CDI Jelisaveta Petrović CM : Communication and Media XIII(44) 35-56Abstract: The aim of this paper is to examine the characteristics of the relationship between political activism and plans for emigration among the participants of the protest Against dictatorship. A survey of the protest participants was conducted in three cities -Belgrade, Nis and Subotica (N = 175), during the spring of 2017. The paper starts from the " exit-voice" theoretical model, developed by economist Albert Hirschman (1970). Applied in a political context, this model links polit...

show abstract

Resistant exit

Cited by 8 publications

References 40 publications

Literary Devices: Teaching Social Contract Theory with A Short Story

Literary Devices: Teaching Social Contract Theory with A Short Story

Discursive Exit

'Walking - not to walk away!': Activism and emigration from the perspective of the protestors Against dictatorship

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About