During magnetic storms, solar-magnetosphere-ionosphere-Earth interactions give rise to geomagnetically induced currents (GICs) in man-made technological conductors such as power grids, gas pipelines, and railway networks with potentially damaging outcomes. Generally, electrically conductive regions of the Earth are assumed to be less at risk to GICs than resistive ones, since induced electric fields associated with GICs are linearly related to given magnetic source fields via Earth's impedance. Here, we show that magnetic source fields associated with storms can be enhanced by secondary electromagnetic (EM) induction in Earth's electrically conductive asthenosphere and that this previously neglected effect can give rise to larger electric fields close to the lithosphere-asthenosphere boundary in regions where the conductance of the asthenosphere is higher. Our analysis of data from the 30 October 2003 "Halloween" and 8 September 2017 storms shows that the magnitudes of electric fields from both storms are affected by lithospheric plate thickness and asthenosphere conductance (conductivity-thickness product) and that they are 5 times larger in southern Sweden (>5 V/km for the 30 October 2003 "Halloween" storm) than in central Scotland. Our results provide insight into why Sweden experienced a storm-related power outage in 2003, whereas Scotland did not. Plain Language Summary Space weather is generated by changes in the rate at which the Sun emits high-velocity, charged particles (plasma) that are collectively referred to as the "solar wind." Just as extreme atmospheric perturbations cause meteorological storms whose high-velocity winds can damage ground-based infrastructure, extreme electromagnetic perturbations of Earth's magnetosphere and ionosphere due to fluctuations in solar-wind pressure cause magnetic storms that drive hazardous currents that are quasi-DC (direct current) through ground-based linear conductors-power networks, gas pipelines, and railways. These currents, referred to as "geomagnetically induced currents" or "GICs," can trip electricity transformers, corrode gas pipelines, and cause railway signal failure. GIC hazards depend not only on external factors but also on the Earth itself, because the external magnetic source fields interact with Earth's deep electrical conductivity-that is, electric fields that drive surficial GICs are induced deeper within the Earth. Here, we investigate how the regionally variable thickness of Earth's quasi-rigid outer, electrically resistive shell-the "tectonic plate" or "lithosphere"-and region-dependent conductance of the underlying electrically conductive layer known as the "asthenosphere" modify surface electric fields making some regions of the world inherently more vulnerable to extreme space weather events than others.