Practical Reasons and Reasonable Practice: The Case of Euthanasia in The Netherlands

Abstract

Since the early 1970s the issue of euthanasia has been intensely debated in The Netherlands. Through these debates knowledge about medical practices involving the end of life was no longer confined to medical or legal quarters, but became public to a large extent. Following public opinion changes, the legal reaction to euthanasia changed. By prosecuting test cases the public prosecutors allowed the Dutch Supreme Court to formulate specific conditions in which euthanasia would go unpunished. The political debate about changing the criminal law, which still holds that euthanasia is a serious crime, developed at a much slower pace. Several extensive empirical studies were undertaken to gain valid knowledge about the medical practices. This article is concerned with a presentation of the various debates and the changes that took place in the fields of criminal law, politics, and medicine. The main conclusion is the hypothesis that a more open climate for medical practices concerning the end of life allows society to better control these practices.

Attitude towards Euthanasia among Medical Students: A Cross-Sectional Study in Hong Kong

“…There are many concerns associated with the decision to legalize euthanasia. Firstly, social culture and values are important to consider [12]. Many papers highlight that people in African countries are less supportive of euthanasia than Europeans [13].…”

Elderly Israelis and their family members meanings towards euthanasia.

“…It is a concern for “experts” who have debated the issue for generations, and lay persons who are required to make decisions for themselves or for an incompetent family member. The involvement of different people from a variety of professional disciplines has caused researchers to conclude that euthanasia is one of the most important and controversial issues of the new century (Hessing, Blad & Peiterman, 1996).…”

My Parent’s Dignified Death is Different from Mine: Moral Problem Solving about Euthanasia

“…A parents' death, compared with other deaths, elicited strong emotional reactions and was associated with reasoning struggles that involved a wide range of role perspectives; a moral orientation of care; and value priorities of honor through loyalty, compassion and devotion. KEY WORDS • euthanasia • moral problem solving End-of-life decisions are among the most profound moral problems of our century (Brigham & Pfeifer, 1996) and among the universal questions that people have to face (Hessing, Blad, & Pieterman, 1996…”