“Poison to the Economy”: (Un-)Taxing the Wealthy in the German Federal Parliament from 1996 to 2016

Abstract

The concentration of wealth is a key component of the rise in economic inequality at the beginning of the twenty-first century. While the abolition of taxes on private wealth during the 1990s and 2000s is recognized as an important institutional driver behind this development, comparatively little is known about the justification of tax cuts for the wealthy in advanced democracies. This paper investigates how the abolishment of the personal net wealth tax in Germany, a country with high levels of wealth inequality, has been debated and justified in parliament over a period of 20 years. Using a mixed methods approach that combines computational social science methods and a qualitative analysis, we examine how Germany’s two major parties, the Christian Democrats (CDU) and the Social Democrats (SPD), have variously construed the meaning and purpose of the wealth tax and justified their support for or opposition to it. While the Social Democrats debate the wealth tax primarily from a social justice perspective, the Christian Democrats rely on an efficiency frame that invokes biological metaphors, enabling them to narrate the wealth tax as a threat to the social body. Paradoxically, then, by arguing that the tax is “poison to the economy”, conservative discourse succeeds in linking opposition to the wealth tax to a principle of social unity. On these grounds, we suggest that future research should scrutinize how the interrelation between political discourse and institutional architectures has facilitated the rise of wealth inequality in recent decades.

Making the rich pay? Social democracy and wealth taxation in Europe in the aftermath of the great financial crisis

“…Klitgaard and Paster (2021) show, in a comparative case study of Austria and Sweden, that the Social Democrats supported repealing inheritance taxes due to a mix of business demands and electoral concerns. Focusing on parliamentary debates on the NWT in Germany, Hilmar and Sachweh (2022) show that the Social Democrats ceded to defend a reintroduction of this tax since the early 2000s, increasingly adopting right-wing arguments depicting the tax as 'irrational fiscal policy' or avoiding a debate about it altogether. These findings are in line with the broader argument that social democratic parties became increasingly concerned with their reputation for economic competence in contexts of growing fiscal pressure, leading them to adopt economically conservative policies for electoral concerns (Kraft, 2017;Bremer, 2018).…”

Deserving more? A vignette study on the role of self-interest and deservingness opinions for popular support for wealth taxation in Germany

“…While the opposition at the timethe Social Democrats, the Green Party, and the Left Partydemanded a constitutionally compliant design and a reintroduction of the wealth tax, these plans were not followed up on a few years later under the SPD-led red-green federal government(Hilmar and Sachweh, 2022). Apart from taxing personal net wealth, capital gains are taxed at a rate of 25 % in Germany, while inheritance tax rates range between 15 % and 40 %(Bach, 2016).…”