Norway and Russia in the Arctic: New Cold War Contamination?

Abstract

The standoff between Russia and the West over Ukraine has already obstructed cooperation across a range of issues. Could it also affect state interaction between Norway and Russia in the Arctic—an area and a relationship long characterized by a culture of compromise and/or cooperation? Here we start from the theoretical premise that states are not pre-constituted political entities, but are constantly in the making. How Russia views its own role and how it views other actors in the Arctic changes over time, calling for differing approaches. That holds true for Norway as well. To clarify the premises for interaction between Russia and Norway in the Arctic, we scrutinize changes in official discourse on Self and Other in the Arctic on both sides in the period 2012 to 2016, to establish what kind of policy mode—“realist,” “institutionalist,” or “diplomatic management”—has underlain the two countries’ official discourse in that period. Has Norway continued to pursue “balancing” policies undertaken in the realist mode with those in the diplomatic management mode? Which modes have characterized Russia’s approach toward Norway? Finding that realist-mode policies increasingly dominate on both sides, in the conclusion we discuss how the changing mode of the one state affects that of the other, and why a New Cold War is now spreading to the Arctic. Responsible Editor: Helge Blakkisrud, Norwegian Institute of International Affairs (NUPI).

Cultures of anarchy: Images of Russia in the narrative of Norwegian mainstream news media during the Ukraine crisis 2014

“…The cooperative relationship in the High North continued to be developed after Putin's takeover as president at the turn of the millennium (Wilhelmsen and Gjerde, 2018). But Russia also gradually asserted its identity as in opposition to a hegemonic West (Åtland et al, 2005;Heier and Kjølberg, 2015).…”

The Strategic Role of Land Power on NATO’s Northern Flank

“…Another example would be the discussions related to the rotational presence of US troops in central and Northern Norway the last few years. 12,13 In addition, thorough studies of the planned territorial defence of Northern Norway during the Cold War have also been released in the last two decades. 14 These are studies of -perhaps -surprisingly high relevance today, as many of the same unique geographical and climatic challenges are just as relevant today as they were during the Cold War, despite technological innovations.…”

“If we want to have a good future, we need to do something about it”. Youth, security and imagined horizons in the intercultural Arctic Norway

“…In the last few years, we have seen an increasing tension in the Arctic, especially related to the relationship between the USA, China, and Russia. It has also been suggested that there is a "new" cold war emerging, which is of great concern for politicians and researchers alike (Wilhelmsen and Gjerde 2018). The Norwegian Arctic is particularly exposed to these international tensions.…”