Multiple scenario development: Its conceptual and behavioral foundation

Abstract

This paper examines the multiple scenario approach as an important corporate innovation in strategic planning. Using a participant/observer perspective, I examine how scenario planning tries to meet certain methodological, organizational and psychological challenges facing today's senior managers. Three prime characteristics are identified as setting the scenario approach apart from more traditional planning tools: (1) the script or narrative approach, (2) uncertainty across rather than within models, and (3) the decomposition of a complex future into discrete states. After exploring the intellectual roots of scenario planning, I examine such organizational aspects as the need for diversity of views and the importance of simplicity and manageability. Both benefits and obstacles to using scenarios in organizations are identified. Cognitive biases are examined as well, especially the well‐known biases of overconfidence and the conjunction fallacy. Two experiments test the impact of scenarios on people's subjective confidence ranges. Another two experiments test the internal coherence of subjects' beliefs. The psychological benefit of scenario planning appears to tie in the exploitation of one set of biases (e.g., conjunction fallacies) to counteract another (such as overconfidence).

Axiomatic foundation and a structured process for developing firm-specific Intuitive Logics scenarios

“…One may compare two sets of scenarios, created using two different approaches, to evaluate if one approach is superior to the other in terms of the quantity and/or quality of insights produced. Such results can inform the literature that empirically examines the cognitive effects of using scenarios [12,76,77]. One may also compare the output of various steps in the process by judging the quantity and/or quality of output (e.g.…”

Foresight capabilities and SME product/service adaptiveness: the moderating effect of industry dynamism

“…A number of practices and techniques have equally been suggested as essentials of foresight with notable ones being scenario planning, environmental scanning, technology road mapping, trend analysis, and real options analysis (Boyd and Fulk, 1996;Sarpong, 2011;Schoemaker, 1993;Vecchiato, 2015). Accordingly, these techniques enable firms to reduce the level of uncertainty and improve the ability of perceiving plausible future changes and challenges that can affect the firm or the entire industry (Amer et al, 2013;Chermack, 2005;Chermack et al, 2001;Paliokaitė et al, 2014).…”

Cenários como ferramenta na gestão ambiental municipal: um estudo de caso em Brotas - SP

“…A essência da metodologia de cenários se relaciona a várias coisas, dentre as quais, arte e ciência; indução e dedução (SCHOEMAKER, 1993 …”