Movement-Related Feedback and Temporal Accuracy in Clarinet Performance

Abstract

SENSORY INFORMATION AVAILABLE WHEN MUSICIANS'fingers arrive on instrument keys contributes to temporal accuracy in piano performance (Goebl & Palmer, 2008). The hypothesis that timing accuracy is related to sensory (tactile) information available at finger-key contact was extended to clarinetists' finger movements during key depressions and releases that, together with breathing, determine the timing of tone onsets. Skilled clarinetists performed melodies at different tempi in a synchronization task while their movements were recorded with motion capture. Finger accelerations indicated consistent kinematic landmarks when fingers made initial contact with or release from the key surface. Performances that contained more kinematic landmarks had reduced timing error. The magnitude of finger accelerations on key contact and release was positively correlated with increased temporal accuracy during the subsequent keystroke. These findings suggest that sensory information available at finger-key contact enhances the temporal accuracy of music performance. W HAT ROLE DOES TACTILE AND proprioceptive feedback play in the production of fast finger sequences typical of music performance? Instruments such as piano, strings, and wind instruments require fine control of finger movements in order to generate performances with high temporal precision and accuracy. The arrival of fingers on instrumental surfaces can provide important sensory information to guide performance. The precision of finger movements is attributed in part to the receptors distributed in the skin of the fingertips; these tactile sensory inputs permit high sensitivity and subsequent response to changes in force loads (Flanagan & Johansson, 2002). Tactile feedback may be more salient than proprioceptive sensations, due to the high density of mechanoreceptor innervation in the finger-tip skin and the large cortical areas involved in processing tactile information from the fingers (Jones, 1996).Although there are few studies of sensory feedback from finger-key contact in music performance, several studies of sensory feedback during tapping tasks indicate that tactile information plays an important role in the control of timing. Aschersleben and colleagues proposed the Sensory Accumulator Model (SAM) to explain how people synchronize finger tapping with an auditory pacing sequence, and how this synchronization is influenced by tactile information (Aschersleben, Gehrke, & Prinz, 2001). When participants tap in synchrony with an auditory pacing sequence, their taps precede the pacing sequence, termed a negative asynchrony (Aschersleben, 2002). According to SAM, the brain registers the time of a tap when afferent signals associated with the tap accumulate past a certain threshold, which is compared with the time at which the brain receives information from the metronome's onset. Based on the assumption that tactile information from the finger accumulates more slowly than auditory information from the metronome, participants must tap before the metronome's onset to ...

The influence of cellist's postural movements on their musical expressivity

“…Le développement des capacités d'anticipation corporelle du pianiste semble ainsi lié à différents niveaux de contraintes temporelles, et principalement celle du respect du tempo [Drake 2000]. D'autres études ont révélé l'importance de l'anticipation pour une bonne coordination des gestes effecteurs, telles que l'accélération des doigts du clarinettiste [Palmer 2009b], la pression du souffle du trompettiste [Bianco 2009], ou les vitesses de la baguette du percussioniste [Dahl 2000].…”

A narrative review on haptic devices: relating the physiology and psychophysical properties of the hand to devices for rehabilitation in central nervous system disorders

“…Thermoreceptive units are divided into two groups, warm and cold receptors, the latter of which are more numerous throughout epidermal and dermal skin layers [8] Tactile somatosensory information is vital for normal grasping activities, for instance, tactile information about surface texture and object shape [24] is vital to ensuring correct grasp pressures. Tactile information is also necessary for tasks requiring rapid dextrous finger movement such as piano [25] or clarinet playing [26]. The absence of normal tactile feedback results in clumsiness in daily activities [27].…”

Distinct digit kinematics by professional and amateur pianists

“…A wide variety of tasks require controlling dynamic movement of individual digits as in playing a musical instrument where the precision of pressing, striking or plucking by one or more digits determines the quality of the performance (Albrecht et al 2014; Furuya et al 2011; Goebl and Palmer 2013; Keller et al 2010; Palmer et al 2009). Dynamic patterns of covariation among joints within and across digits are observed during these movements in addition to other tasks such as typing, American Sign Language, and in grasping and manipulating objects (e.g.…”