Montessori-Based Activities Among Persons with Late-Stage Dementia: Evaluation of Mental and Behavioral Health Outcomes

Abstract

Objectives Literature regarding Montessori-based activities with older adults with dementia is fairly common with early stages of dementia. Conversely, research on said activities with individuals experiencing late-stage dementia is limited because of logistical difficulties in sampling and data collection. Given the need to understand risks and benefits of treatments for individuals with late-stage dementia, specifically regarding their mental and behavioral health, this study sought to evaluate the effects of a Montessori-based activity program implemented in a long-term care facility. Method Utilizing an interrupted time series design, trained staff completed observation-based measures for 43 residents with late-stage dementia at three intervals over six months. Empirical measures assessed mental health (anxiety, psychological well-being, quality of life) and behavioral health (problem behaviors, social engagement, capacity for activities of daily living). Results Group differences were observed via repeated measures ANOVA and paired-samples t-tests. The aggregate, longitudinal results-from baseline to final data interval-for the psychological and behavioral health measures were as follows: problem behaviors diminished though not significantly; social engagement decreased significantly; capacities for activities of daily living decreased significantly; quality of life increased slightly but not significantly; anxiety decreased slightly but not significantly; and psychological well-being significantly decreased. Conclusion Improvements observed for quality of life and problem behaviors may yield promise for Montessori-based activities and related health care practices. The rapid physiological and cognitive deterioration from late-stage dementia should be considered when interpreting these results.

Effects of Cognitive Rehabilitation on the Psychological Capital of the Elderly with Dementia

“…It was found that this method improved the quality of life of the elderly with dementia. Contrary to the results of the present study, Wilks (2019) (17) observed that the Montessori method significantly reduced the individuals' psychological well-being, social interactions, and capacity for daily activities. However, it caused a slight increase in the quality of life and a slight decrease in anxiety and problematic behaviors.…”

Clinical Observation on the Effect of Systematic Nursing Intervention on Cognitive Function, Life Activity Ability, and Quality of Life of Senile Dementia Patients

“…Adjust the diet reasonably to meet the nutritional intake, strengthen exercise, strengthen body resistance, and promote the metabolism. Finally, health education and nursing should be carried out, and patients and their families should be actively taught disease-related knowledge and nursing methods, so as to promote the effective treatment for patients and reduce the risk of bad behavior and mental health outcomes [11].…”

Effectiveness of Montessori-based activities on agitation among Asian patients with dementia: A systematic review and meta-analysis

“…However in another relevant study, Montessori based activity was not proven effective on problem behaviors diminished in severe dementia patients. [ 5 ] The inconsistent outcomes on agitation may lead to confusing understanding of the efficacy of Montessori-based activity in dementia patients. Moreover, the majority of studies enrolled patients with small sample size (<100 patients), which may limit the reliability of the conclusions.…”