Mixing methods in a qualitatively driven way

Abstract

A B S T R AC T This article makes an argument for a 'qualitatively driven' approach to mixing methods. It focuses on the value of mixed-methods approaches for researching questions about social experience and lived realities. It suggests that 'qualitative thinking' is a useful starting point for mixing methods, but that it is ultimately more helpful to think in terms of multi-dimensional research strategies that transcend or even subvert the so-called qualitativequantitative divide. Mixing methods helps us to think creatively and 'outside the box', to theorize beyond the micro-macro divide, and to enhance and extend the logic of qualitative explanation. Mixedmethods approaches raise challenges in reconciling different epistemologies and ontologies, and in integrating different forms of data and knowledge. The article argues that we should think more in terms of 'meshing' or 'linking' than 'integrating' data and method. It goes on to argue for the development of 'multi-nodal' dialogic explanations that allow the distinctiveness of different methods and approaches to be held in creative tension. The article concludes with a discussion of qualitatively derived principles for mixing methods. K E Y W O R D S : lived realities, mixed methods, multi-dimensional methods, qualitative methods, social experience A RT I C L E

Cultivating equanimity through mindfulness meditation: A mixed methods enquiry into the development of decentring capabilities in men

“…Of course, in terms of the quantitative data alone, this possibility cannot be substantiated due to the primary limitation of the study: the absence of a control group. (The reason for this omission is that, unlike most mixed methods research, the research was 'qualitatively driven' (Mason, 2006), and therefore did not prioritize a conventional experimental design. That is, the primary focus of the research was qualitative interviews, with quantitative data gathered as an adjunct to this for the purposes of 'interrogating' or elucidating the qualitative data.)…”

Las dimensiones del bienestar de niños y niñas que viven en Buenos Aires, Argentina.

“…La incorporación de la creatividad (Bagnoli, 2009), puede alentar a pensar fuera de la caja, generando nuevas formas de interrogar y comprender (Mason, 2006). Los dibujos pueden funcionar también como disparadores o rompehielos (Morrow, 1998); también ha prosperado el desarrollo de métodos basados en el arte, como, por ejemplo, el autorretrato, la elicitación gráfica /y la línea del tiempo (Bagnoli, 2009;Boydell et al, 2012).…”

Tri prvine konstrukcije prostorske identitete v soseskah Mađir v Banjaluki (Bosna in Hercegovina) in Ilsvika v Trondheimu (Norveška)

“…Avtorja sta uporabila kvalitativno metodo za proučevanje konstrukcije prostorske identitete, odvisne od različnih tež-ko izmerljivih dejavnikov (Mason, 2006). Kot navaja Manuel Castells (2009), ta proces vedno poteka v kontekstu, ki ga določajo različna razmerja moči, in vključuje različne elemente zgodovine, geografije, veroizpovedi, spolne usmerjenosti itd.…”