Mismatches in the Ecosystem Services Literature—a Review of Spatial, Temporal, and Functional-Conceptual Mismatches

Abstract

Purpose of Review The objective of this review is to identify commonly researched ecosystem service mismatches, including mismatches concerning management and policies implemented to manage ecosystem service delivery. It additionally discusses how mismatches affect the ability to develop effective policies and management guidelines for ecosystem services. Recent Findings Recent ecosystem service literature considers mismatches in the ecosystem, the social system, and as social-ecological interactions. These mismatches occur over three dimensions: spatial, temporal, and functional-conceptual. The research field incorporates not only ecological aspects but also social ones like the management and governance of ecosystem services. However, the focus of the reviewed literature is mainly on spatial and temporal dimensions of mismatches and the production of scientific knowledge, rather than the implementation of the knowledge in management and policies. Summary Research on ecosystem service mismatches reflects the complexity and interconnectedness of social-ecological systems as it encompasses a broad variety of approaches. However, temporal mismatches received less attention than spatial mismatches, especially in regard to social and social-ecological aspects and could be a topic for future research. Furthermore, in order to develop effective policies and management guidelines, research must work closer with decision-makers to not only advance scientific understanding of ecosystem service mismatches but also create understanding and support the uptake of this knowledge.

Why reconnect to nature in times of crisis? Ecosystem contributions to the resilience and well‐being of people going back to the land in Greece

“…Third, these material and nonmaterial ecosystem benefits are valued differently depending on specific crisis contexts and as such vary temporally (Winkler et al., 2021). Meaning that some benefits are only valued at certain times and usually ignored at other times.…”

Diagnosis of Labor and Human Evolution: Why Is It so Difficult to Diagnose Labor in Humans? The Contribution of Metabolomics

“…There are numerous examples of mismatches in the literature [52]. Most species have evolved as niche constructors [53] creating a constant environment through their activities and behaviors, all leading to a situation of equilibrium. Modern humans, on the other hand, constantly change their environment, rather than creating balance, they live in the constant instability that they themselves produce.…”

Food System Resilience: Concepts, Issues, and Challenges

“…It is important to distinguish short-term interruptions due to shocks (e.g., bad weather or an IT malfunction interrupting just-in-time fresh grocery deliveries) from disruptions due to stresses that affect the longer term (e.g., changing dietary preferences, shifting cropping regions). It is also important to understand the interactions between the two and the notion of temporal mismatches (89). In the context of dynamically shifting risk environments, strategies to enhance resilience over a shorter timescale may deplete resilience over the longer term, necessitating specification of the time frame over which resilience is being considered (90).…”