Making sense of reflection: a comparison of beginning and experienced teachers’ perceptions of reflection for practice

Abstract

The importance of reflection for learning has been emphasised in professional education programmes. In teacher education, a number of researchers have claimed the success of various initiatives in developing teachers as reflective practitioners. However, there appear to be few studies comparing and contrasting beginning and experienced teachers' perceptions of the usefulness of reflection for practice. The study reported here examined how reflection was used by experienced and beginning teachers who were formally introduced to the same model of reflection. The data were collected as part of two separate qualitative studies, one a study of 12 beginning teachers and one of 12 experienced teachers, via semi-structured interviews. The findings suggested that both groups of teachers moved from being somewhat sceptical about reflection, to embracing reflection as a tool to analyse and modify their practice. A major difference between the two groups related to the scope, focus and impact of their reflective activities.

The use of reflective journaling as a learning strategy during the clinical rotations of students from the faculty of health sciences: An action-research study

“…At present, a new teaching model is suggested for stimulating significant student learning: this model relies on higher-order thinking processes, and represents a continuum of learning via the implementation of methodological strategies that are able to evoke reflective thought processes. Consequently, reflective learning is currently very popular in professional education programmes (Williams and Grudnoff, 2011).…”

Mentoría pedagógica para profesorado universitario novel: estado de la cuestión y análisis de buenas prácticas

“…En este proyecto, Billet revela que en China, Grecia, Europa y culturas de Asia Central, el aprendizaje a través de la observación, la imitación y la práctica es muy efi caz para integrar a nuevos profesionales. Este tipo de aprendizaje mimético favorece un modelo de refl exión práctica que se basa en el apoyo, la retroalimentación y la mentoría del profesorado experimentado (Williams y Gudonoff, 2011).…”

Case for reflection in engineering education- and an alternative

“…Thus the widely acclaimed suggestions in the keynote texts on reflection for learning (Schön, 1983[15]; Kolb, 1984[16]; Boud et al,1985[17]) have been taken up for some time in educational programmes and schemes for professional development (Bourner, 2003[7]); Williams and Grudnoff, 2011 [18]). Generally learners are encouraged to consider both past and impending actions, with a view to effecting future enhancement (Hatton and Smith, 1995[19]).…”