“…However, because most of this work is confined to certain regions with limited availability of sedimentary records and accurate dates, the distribution of desert boundaries varies between different studies, and this needs to be more thoroughly investigated. In addition, little is known about the nature of vegetation change in the deserts of northern China, although this has a dramatic effect on sand mobility [Lu et al, 2005;Qiang et al, 2013] and desertification [Sun, 2000]. Although there are many vegetation reconstructions based on pollen analysis of individual sites in the dry lands of northern China [Gao et al, 1992[Gao et al, , 1993Jiang et al, 2006;Yang et al, 2012;Sun and Feng, 2013], most of these studies focus on climate change over time rather than on spatial patterns.…”