Improving the effectiveness of service delivery in the public healthcare sector: the case of ophthalmology services in Malaysia

Abstract

BackgroundRising demand of ophthalmology care is increasingly straining Malaysia’s public healthcare sector due to its limited human and financial resources. Improving the effectiveness of ophthalmology service delivery can promote national policy goals of population health improvement and system sustainability. This study examined the performance variation of public ophthalmology service in Malaysia, estimated the potential output gain and investigated several factors that might explain the differential performance.MethodsData for 2011 and 2012 on 36 ophthalmology centres operating in the Ministry of Health hospitals were used in this analysis. We first consulted a panel of ophthalmology service managers to understand the production of ophthalmology services and to verify the production model. We then assessed the relative performance of these centres using Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). Efficiency scores (ES) were decomposed into technical, scale, and congestion component. Potential increase in service output was estimated. Sensitivity analysis of model changes was performed and stability of the result was assessed using bootstrap approach. Second stage Tobit regression was conducted to determine if hospital type, availability of day services and population characteristics were related to the DEA scores.ResultsIn 2011, 33 % of the ophthalmology centres were found to have ES > 1 (mean ES = 1.10). Potential output gains were 10 % (SE ± 2.92), 7.4 % (SE ± 2.06), 6.9 % (SE ± 1.97) if the centres could overcome their technical, scale and congestion inefficiencies. More centres moved to the performance frontier in 2012 (mean ES = 1.07), with lower potential output gain. The model used has good stability. Robustness checks show that the DEA correctly identified low performing centres. Being in state hospital was significantly associated with better performance.ConclusionsUsing DEA to benchmarking service performance of ophthalmology care could provide insights for policy makers and service managers to intuitively visualise the overall performance of resource use in an otherwise difficult to assess scenario. The considerable potential output gain estimated indicates that effort should be invested to understand what drove the performance variation and optimise them. Similar performance assessment should be undertaken for other healthcare services in the country in order to work towards a sustainable health system.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12913-015-1011-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Evaluation of performance and impacts of maternal and child health hospital services using Data Envelopment Analysis in Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, China: a comparison study among poverty and non-poverty county level hospitals

“…So we choose to follow the maximum likelihood estimation of the Tobit regression model to evaluate the factors that affect the efficiency of the county-level MCHH. The model is as follows [13]: Firstly, we has definition a latent variable model: y i *  =  β  '  x i  +  u i .,here y i . the observable variable, then…”

Healthcare systems and Covid19: Lessons to be learnt from efficient countries

“…The strength and ease of use of this method has attracted many researchers to develop models that rank hospital departments; compare healthcare services, and establish the efficiencies of clinics (i.e. surgery, gynaecology) in hospitals between countries [6][7][8][9][10][11][12] ).…”

Estimates of visual impairment and its causes from the National Eye Survey in Malaysia (NESII)

“…Cataract was the major cause of bilateral blindness accounting for 39% of total estimated cases. A report using Data Development Analysis noted most public ophthalmological centers could increase output with existing capacity [ 6 ]. In view of the scarcity of current prevalence data for visual impairment and blindness, we embarked on the National Eye Survey II (NES II) using Rapid Assessment of Avoidable Blindness (RAAB) methodology to estimate the prevalence of visual impairment among the elderly in Malaysia.…”