Idealised versus tainted femininity: discourses of the menstrual experience in Australian magazines that target young women

Abstract

Information and messages concerning health-related issues are not confined to material provided by official figures or sources. Much information exists in the community and comes from a variety of sources. One such source is the media. This paper reports the findings of a study conducted over a 12-month period of advertisements for menstrual products in a selection of four monthly Australian magazines (n = 48) directed towards young women. The study examined the way in which menstruation and the menstrual experience were depicted in terms of page space, textual content and visual images. Findings revealed that advertisements for menstrual products provided confusing, conflicting and paradoxical messages. These included stressing the normality of menstruation while also emphasising the importance of keeping it hidden and secret. Menstruation was depicted as being a state of tainted (idealised) femininity because of the potential for the menstrual silence to be shattered by people finding out. Protection failure was depicted as being the ultimate in tainted femininity and a result of a woman's incorrect choice of product. Choosing menstrual-care products was depicted as simple but, paradoxically, complex and confusing. Women were depicted as liberated and sophisticated but images and language related to infancy were used. Freedom and liberation were conferred by the use of the advertised product. Overall, in common with previous studies, menstruation was depicted as a crisis of hygiene that is a risk to femininity. Advertisements for pantyliners suggest that femininity itself poses a threat to (idealised) femininity. This study demonstrates the crucial role of the media as a source of health information for young women.

Primary health care content in Australian undergraduate nursing curricula

“…Stolley and Hill (1996) referred to this in their content analysis study of the elderly in undergraduate sociology course text books as 'unique page space'. This was also successfully used in the nursing literature to demonstrate the role of the media as a source of health information for young women (Raftos, Jackson, & Mannix, 1998). However, the heterogeneity of undergraduate nursing websites we sampled did not facilitate a similar unit of metric.…”

Taboo in consumption: Social structure, gender and sustainable menstrual products

“…The prevalence of taboos around menstruation have forced companies and governments to develop carefully worded communications that are mindful of prevalent cultural sensitivity (Sommer et al, ). In fact, in some instances, marketing has made matters worse by encouraging secrecy and shame (Malviya & Raghavan, ; Raftos, Jackson, & Mannix, ; Winkler & Roaf, ). Thus, beliefs and values influence not only what and how information is communicated, but also whether it is appropriate to communicate any information at all (Hoerster et al, ).…”

A Study into Public Awareness of the Environmental Impact of Menstrual Products and Product Choice

“…It is this taboo that creates a difficult arena for discussion of more sustainable alternatives. Feminist critiques claim that disposable menstrual products are loaded with patriarchal ideas that suggest menstruation is an unhygienic problem and one that should be hidden [7]. Berkeley [8] explains the increased use of these items by women's entry into more male-dominated workplaces.…”