“…For example, water-limited regions where 18 O has high magnitude and frequency variability (e.g. Dennison et al, 2013;Treble et al, 2017). In waterlimited environments, several potential mechanisms have been proposed to significantly affect speleothem 18 O, including: 1) evaporative fractionation of 18 O in the soil, shallow vadose zone or cave; 2) selective recharge, whereby rainfall events with high magnitude or intensity have a distinct isotopic composition, typically low 18 O; and 3) non-equilibrium deposition during speleothem formation (Cuthbert et al, 2014;Pape et al, 2010;Dreybrodt and Scholz, 2011;Markowska et al, 2016).…”