How are citizens involved in smart cities? Analysing citizen participation in Japanese ``Smart Communities''

Abstract

International audienceIn recent years, ``smart cities'' have rapidly increased in discourses as well as in their real number, and raise various issues. While citizen engagement is a key element of most definitions of smart cities, information and communication technologies (ICTs) would also have great potential for facilitating public participation. However, scholars have highlighted that little research has focused on actual practices of citizen involvement in smart cities so far. In this respect, the authors analyse public participation in Japanese ``Smart Communities'', paying attention to both official discourses and actual practices. Smart Communities were selected in 2010 by the Japanese government which defines them as ``smart city'' projects and imposed criteria such as focus on energy issues, participation and lifestyle innovation. Drawing on analysis of official documents as well as on interviews with each of the four Smart Communities' stakeholders, the paper explains that very little input is expected from Japanese citizens. Instead, ICTs are used by municipalities and electric utilities to steer project participants and to change their behaviour. The objective of Smart Communities would not be to involve citizens in city governance, but rather to make them participate in the co-production of public services, mainly energy production and distribution

Digital Platform-Enabled Community Development: A Case Study of a Private-Public Partnership Sustainability Initiative

“…The role of communities in enacting technologydriven sustainability initiatives and change is particularly important, as like-minded groups, organizations and governing institutions must seek to work in partnership to use IT to transform their circumstances in significant ways [9,17]. Also, technology-driven cities provide open and user-driven ecosystems [16,18].…”

“…Extant literature suggests that IT can play an important role in sustainability initiatives [4,5]. For example, scholars established that IT can enable community development [6], whereby community members come together to take collective action and generate solutions to common problems [7], such as the sustainability of their cities and communities [8,9]. IT can also support initiatives that target the building and construction sector [10], such as mass customization of housing [11].…”

Expected Participation and Mentality of Smart Citizen in Smart Cities

“…Although this view has been still less pronounced compared to the technological view, its significance has been increasing (see the analysed corpus below). Scholarly sources have been following this slow movement (among others Benoit and Hiroko, 2016;Thomas et al, 2016). It is noticeable that the number of academic papers about the role of smart citizens is also rising intensively in the above mentioned databases.…”

La stratégie de la « smart city » au Japon : expérimentations nationales et circulations globales

“…Le contact avec la population, à travers sa réactivité face aux requêtes de DR ou encore dans ses choix de consommation énergétique ou de mobilité, est également une composante essentielle de la vérification dans des conditions « réelles » de ces technologies (Granier et Kudo, 2015). Cette diversité des technologies et systèmes sociaux interroge l'idée d'un modèle unique au Japon, même si les modalités « politiques » de mise en place sont les mêmes pour toutes les expérimentations.…”