Generic Reference in English, Arabic and Malay: A Cross Linguistic Typology and Comparison

Abstract

According to the Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English 1999 by Biber et al. (p. 266) generic article uses are more than twice as common in academic English than in conversation or fiction. This is an area that English for Academic Purpose (EPA) textbooks and teachers would need to target more than general English teaching. This paper is therefore a contribution towards better understanding of what linguistic facts about generics teachers and textbooks of EAP might need to cover in order to deal with them satisfactorily, particularly for learners with Arabic or Malay as L1. This paper is also significant as it is the first to compare the expression of generic meanings by noun phrases in three typologically quite different languages: the Germanic language English, the Semitic language Arabic and the Austronesian language Malay. The contrast between the three languages is substantial in that they have different settings according to the nominal mapping parameter (NMP), which captures some widespread generalizations about the occurrence of mass and countable nouns and articles in the languages of the world. As a part of a bigger project that investigates the acquisition and interpretation of generic reference by speakers of these languages, this article is descriptive and comparative in nature. The main finding is that the rules for mapping forms to generic meanings are more complex in English than in Malay or Arabic, in that English marks the difference between NP level and S level genericity and between established and non-established categories.

Count/Mass Nouns and Definiteness in Palestinian Arabic Heritage Speakers of English

“…Semantic countability is expressed by the definiteness system in English, but not in PA. PA and English definiteness systems interfere with Arabic native speakers' acquisition of English as a second language (Harb, 2014;Husni and Newman, 2015). There is strong evidence of the effects of Arabic countability properties in their errors (in which countability significantly interferes with abstractness as well) (Aboras 2020;Alenizi 2013Alenizi , 2017Al-Malki et al 2014;Naim-Bader 1988). Arabic learners of English overuse the definite article in idioms, with abstract and uncountable nouns, and in generic plural noun phrases: (7) *the value of the time (8) *he sell the apples at the crossroad (9) * the milk is nutritious to the body (10) *I went to the bed (11) *you cook the rice (12) *the horses are useful animals.…”

Investigating Kurdish Efl University Students’ Awareness and Production in Using English Generic Reference in Writing

“…The outstanding contributors to the study of generic reference are (e.g. Wijaya, 2012;AL-Malki et al, 2014;Tomás, 2016). Wijaya's study is titled Teaching English Generic Nouns: The Exploration of The Generic Idea in English and Indonesian and The Applications of Explicit Instruction in Classroom.…”

The Acquisition of Definiteness and Specificity in English: A Case Study with Saudi-Arabic Learners of English Using an Online Task

“…Arabic speakers with different dialects commonly drop the indefinite article. Al-Malki, Majid, and Mohd Omar (2014) found that most Arabic dialects tend to drop the indefinite article (nunnation), except in the cases of a few Bedouin dialects. Saudi Arabic speakers tend to drop the indefinite and the absence of the definite article (al-) by using bare nouns to indicate the indefinite context in Saudi Arabic.…”