Gaps in Capacity for Respiratory Care in Developing Countries. Nigeria as a Case Study

Abstract

There are unmet needs for respiratory medical care in developing countries. We sought to evaluate the quality and capacity for respiratory care in low- and lower-middle-income countries, using Nigeria as a case study. We obtained details of the respiratory practice of consultants and senior residents (fellows) in respiratory medicine in Nigeria via a semistructured questionnaire administered to physician attendees at the 2013 National Congress of the Nigerian Thoracic Society. Out of 76 society-registered members, 48 attended the congress, 40 completed the questionnaire, and 35 provided complete data (73% adjusted response rate). Respondents provided information on the process and costs of respiratory medicine training and facility, equipment, and supply capacities at the institutions they represented. Approximately 83% reported working at a tertiary level (teaching) hospital; 91% reported capacity for sputum smear analysis for acid alcohol-fast bacilli, 37% for GeneXpert test cartridges, and 20% for BACTEC liquid sputum culture. Only 34% of respondents could perform full spirometry on patients, and none had the capacity for performing a methacholine challenge test or for measuring the diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide. We estimated the proportion of registered respiratory physicians to the national population at 1 per 2.3 million individuals. Thirteen states with an estimated combined population of 57.7 million offer no specialist respiratory services. Barriers to development of this capacity include the high cost of training. We conclude that substantial gaps exist in the capacity and quality of respiratory care in Nigeria, a pattern that probably mirrors most of sub-Saharan Africa and other countries of similar economic status. Health policy makers should address these gaps systematically.

General Thoracic Surgery in Rwanda: An Assessment of Surgical Volume and of Workforce and Material Resource Deficits

“…Pre- and post-operative assessment such as spirometry, diffusion capacity, and advanced imaging remains challenging in much of Africa due to cost of personnel training and equipment. [36] Plain films and computed tomography are available on site with MRI is available only at KFH. Meanwhile, most pathology and microbiology can be performed in-house or sent to an outside facility for formal interpretation.…”

FVC and FEV Reference Values for Beninese Individuals Aged 17 - 20 Years

“…erences of NHANES III [17], Crapo et al (1981) [26], Knudson et al (1983) [27] and European standards respectively [18]. Similarly, Olanrewaju (1991) showed that Nigerian school children aged 5 to 20 years have average FVC, FEV and DEP values significantly lower than their Caucasian counterparts [28] [29]. These results revealed average values for FVC and FEV calculated on the basis of the ERS-93 [10] standards, which significantly exceed (p < 0.05) the Beninese standard spirometric values.…”

The East African Training Initiative. A Model Training Program in Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine for Low-Income Countries

“…Data from the World Bank indicate that the lowest-income countries in the world have, in general, one-tenth the number of physicians as high-income nations on a per capita basis (5). It is safe to assume that whereas in high-income countries the physician labor supply includes generalists, specialists, and subspecialists, in low-income countries the physician labor supply consists largely of generalists, many of whom have little or no post-graduate training after medical school (6).…”