From practice to theory: emerging lessons from Asia for building urban climate change resilience

Abstract

This paper aims to capture and analyze emerging experiences, lessons and tensions evident from several years of work underway through the Asian Cities Climate Change Resilience Network, a network of secondary cities in South and Southeast Asia that have engaged in a process to analyze vulnerabilities and plan and implement measures to address them. With the support of the Rockefeller Foundation and numerous partners, these cities have identified more than 59 specific resiliencebuilding measures, of which 23 are being implemented. Through this work we see 10 critical urban climate change resilience action areas that cities must consider in order to strengthen their ability to anticipate, prepare for and respond to the types of sudden and slow onset impacts. These are: climate sensitive land use and urban planning; institutional coordination mechanisms and capacity support; drainage, flood and solid waste management; water demand and conservation systems; emergency management and early warning systems; responsive health systems; resilient housing and transport systems; strengthening of ecosystem services; diversification and protection of climate-affected livelihoods; and education and capacity building of citizens. We present case studies of how these measures are implemented in specific cities and highlight the tensions and challenges that have emerged. Primary tensions arise around the powerful political economy forces that influence decisions in cities; ensuring that the risks and benefits of resilience-building measures are distributed equitably; aligning incentives of various stakeholders in cities; and developing the mandates, coordination and capacities needed to manage a multi-scale and multisector issue as complex as urban climate change resilience. This empirical base of practice provides important learning to help guide further the refinement of both theory and practice in the nascent field of urban climate change resilience.

Moving towards inclusive urban adaptation: approaches to integrating community-based adaptation to climate change at city and national scale

“…However, it also highlights the tensions between social, physical, and economic impacts of rapid urban development on local communities, and pressures faced by local officials to accommodate developers and the potential short-term economic benefits they offer (Brown, Dayal, & Rumbaitis del Rio, 2012).…”

Unpacking Resilience for Adaptation: Incorporating Practitioners’ Experiences through a Transdisciplinary Approach to the Case of Drought in Chile

“…For example, participants indicated that community member participation in collective actions needs to be increased; there is a need for community action to improve and broaden citizen engagement, and public awareness should also be increased, consistent with what the literature states [63,64].…”

A Blue Urban Agenda: Adapting to Climate Change in the Coastal Cities of Caribbean and Pacific Small Island Developing States

“…Creating a climate change and environmental focal point or office in a city can help coordinate climate action across government departments or agencies (Roberts, 2008(Roberts, , 2010Anguelovski and Carmin, 2011;Hunt and Watkiss, 2011; OECD, 2011;Brown et al, 2012). Yet, there may be downsides when this function is housed in the environmental line department since it is typically among the weakest parts of city government, with limited influence, as in Jamaica, Trinidad, and Guyana.…”

“…It looks at the performance of each city's complex and interconnected infrastructure and institutional systems, including interdependence between multiple sectors, levels, and risks in a dynamic physical, economic, institutional, and socio-political environment (Gasper, Blohm, and Ruth et al, 2011; Kirshen, Knee, and Ruth et al, 2008). When resilience is considered for cities, certain systemic characteristics are highlighted, such as flexibility, redundancy, responsiveness, capacity to learn, and safe failure (Brown, Dayal, and Rumbaitis et al, 2012;Moench, Tyler, and Lage et al, 2011;Tyler, Reed, MacClune et al, 2010). Resiliency also takes into account the multiple interdependencies between different sectors.…”