Forage options to sustainably intensify smallholder farming systems on tropical sandy soils. A review

Abstract

Intensifying livestock production by integrating perennial forages has great potential to contribute to sustainable development and livelihoods in the Mekong region. However, the approach taken must be informed by the environmental, social, and cultural context of the region. Accordingly, we review published research papers and reports from relevant research for development projects to identify options for sustainably integrating forages into farming systems, with a focus on sand-dominant soils of southern Laos and Cambodia. First, we examine existing livestock management practices to determine the compatibility of forages as an option to intensify livestock production. Second, we review the environmental properties of rainfed lowland rice systems with sandy soils and their implications for forage growing. Third, we identify and compare the suitability of existing forage genetics that is adapted to these environmental properties. Fourth, we propose adapted varieties, outline appropriate management options, and discuss the sustainable engagement of smallholders in the production of forages. The key findings are as follows: (1) Forages appear compatible with the sociocultural properties of smallholder farming systems in southern Laos and Cambodia because there is an awareness of existing limitations to livestock production, widespread desire to possess livestock for cultural reasons, and mounting pressure to improve the productivity of grazing areas and the efficiency of labor.(2) The limiting properties of the environment are drought, soil acidity, flooding, and soil infertility, which must be addressed in the selection and management of forage genetics. (3) Broadly adapted perennial tropical grasses and herbaceous legumes exist, but these are unlikely to thrive in lowland ecosystems of southern Laos and Cambodia that are prone to both annual flooding and drought. (4) Variations in surface hydrology at the farm scale often result in differentiated environments suitable for differing varieties. Brachiaria sp. hybrid "Mulato II," Panicum maximum, and Stylosanthes guianensis are recommended for droughtprone, acidic sands that are safe from prolonged submergence and would require the least additional management, whilst Paspalum atratum is recommended for low-lying areas with access to irrigation. (5) The transition to perennial forage integration appears to be accessible to farmers and can allow them to rapidly accumulate benefits in terms of saved labor; however, efforts to intensify animal production have been slow and must contend with multiple challenges: poor understanding of animal husbandry and health, cultural views relating to the role of animals in production systems, and poor access to forage and livestock services. These must all be addressed if sustainably intensified animal production is to be achieved in these and similar regions.

A Game-Based Approach to Exploring Gender Differences in Smallholder Decisions to Change Farming Practices: White Rice Production in Laos

“…These actions released additional labour to engage in alternative on-farm and off-farm income-generating activities. This finding is very much in line with other studies that show that nontraditional off-farm and nonfarming activities have become integral to the way households generate income in Lao PDR [12][13][14][15], as well as in other emerging economies [75].…”

“…The flip side of the switch to white rice is the threat it carries to preferred subsistence food for the family. Decisions on household agricultural practices are being made in the larger context of industrialization and urbanization, with nontraditional off-farm and nonfarming activities becoming integral to the way that households generate income [12][13][14][15].…”

Urochloa in Tropical Agroecosystems

“…Stylosanthes spp. are native of tropical Americas and used in Africa and Australia, being adapted to low rainfall and low soil fertility (Karia et al, 2011;Philp et al, 2019). The main uses of Stylosanthes are as green manure and in intercrops with perennial crops or grasses in pastures (Karia et al, 2011).…”

What is technology adoption? Exploring the agricultural research value chain for smallholder farmers in Lao PDR

“…Approximately 80 percent of the rural population are smallholder farmers, dependent on rice-based agriculture and livestock, producing on arable land of two to three hectares (Alexander et al 2010;Alexander and Larson 2016;FAO 2017). Farming generally occurs on infertile, poorly structured soils with only marginal land productivity and low returns to labour (Philp et al 2019). Farmers often face climate variability risks in the form of floods and droughts (Roth and Grunbuhel 2012), hence while farmers are generally considering opportunities to increase production and income through more intensive farming activities, many are opting for out-migration and alternative, non-farming, wage opportunities Manivong et al 2014).…”