Fiscal politics in time: pathways to fiscal consolidation in Ireland, Greece, Britain, and Spain, 1980–2012

Abstract

The comparative study of debt and fiscal consolidation has acquired a new focus in the wake of the global financial crisis. This paper re--evaluates the literature on fiscal consolidation that flourished during the 1980s and 1990s. The conventional approach to explanation is based on segmenting episodes of fiscal change into discrete observations. We argue that this misses the dynamic features of government strategy, especially in the choices made between expenditure--based and revenue--based fiscal consolidation strategies. We propose a focus on pathways rather than episodes of adjustment, to capture what Pierson terms 'politics in time'.A case--study approach facilitates analysis of complex causality that includes the structures of interest intermediation, the role of ideas in shaping the set of feasible policy choices, and the situation of national economies in the international political economy. We support our argument with qualitative data based on two case studies, Ireland and Greece, and with additional paired comparisons of Ireland with Britain, and Greece with Spain. Our conclusions suggest that the conventional literature, by excluding key political variables from consideration, may distort our understanding and result in misleading policy prescription.

Economic crisis and youth unemployment: Comparing Greece and Ireland

“…International actors (creditors) feel strongly that Ireland was much more committed to the implementation of the reforms and took ‘ownership’ of the adjustment programmes, while Greece lagged behind, incapable of delivering proposed reforms or complying with its commitments (European Commission, 2015). Recent accounts (Alfonso et al, 2015; Dellepiane-Avellaneda and Hardiman, 2015) have emphasized factors such as interest intermediation, government approaches to social dialogue and different degrees of reform implementation capacities in order to explain diverse policy outcomes.…”

Voters and the IMF: Experimental Evidence From European Crisis Countries

“…The country turned to the IMF again in 2012 and 2015 and exited these programs only in 2018. Under the auspice of the IMF, Greece had to implement massive spending cuts that proved to be very challenging to sustain politically (Dellepiane-Avellaneda & Hardiman, 2015). In the subsequent years, the IMF programs were repeatedly re-negotiated and adjusted.…”

O aumento do imposto sobre a propriedade de veículo automotores em tempo de recessão econômica e o reflexo na sua arrecadação

“…No cenário de desequilíbrio fiscal, os gestores do setor público lançam mão de alternativas que venham ajustar as contas públicas, normalmente, passando pela redução dos gastos ou aumento das receitas (Dellepiane-Avellaneda & Hardiman, 2015). Todavia, a decisão adotada pelo gestor público nem sempre é estritamente técnica, pautada em uma análise prévia das consequências econômicas e sociais decorrentes de sua escolha.…”