Exploring the Benefits and Drawbacks of Age Disclosure among Women Faculty of Color

Abstract

This article is guided by two questions: How is age an important aspect of social location that, when forthcoming about it with students, can be beneficial for pedagogical purposes? and How can women faculty of color—particularly those who appear youthful and/or are younger than most of their colleagues—address the marginality of their actual and/or perceived age while simultaneously operating in a space that is contested for women of color? I highlight four benefits that arose as a result of disclosing my age to students: It (1) enabled me to provide concrete examples that were illustrative of key course concepts, (2) helped students understand how age is relational and contextually significant, (3) facilitated the creation of a safe space for “nontraditional” students, and (4) allowed me to better control the narrative students crafted about me based on their perceptions of me as an instructor.

Navigating Challenges and Teaching Through Lived Experiences as Graduate Student Instructors

“…I am often assumed to be an undergraduate student, and as such, I have learned to make an extra effort to present myself accordingly when in the classroom. Through the clothes I wear, how I style my hair, and the amount of makeup I apply, I take the time to consider how my appearance will effectively communicate my position of authority in the classroom, which is a common issue for women of color in academia (e.g., Gutierrez y Muhs et al 2012;Smith-Tran 2019). For as long as I have been teaching, students are always surprised to see that I am the instructor.…”

“…As instructors of sociology courses which focus on social inequality, we find value in using personal anecdotes to build an empathic connection to help students relate real life experiences to concepts that can seem distant or abstract (Yorks and Kasl 2002). Several scholars have written about the benefits of providing autobiographical examples in the classroom both from instructors (e.g., Smith-Tran 2019;hooks 1994) and between students (e.g., Greenfield 2006). We use these as opportunities to help students draw connections from their-and their classmates'/instructors'-experiences to the course material.…”

Professor–Student Interaction in the Midst of Illness: A Collaborative Autoethnography

“…As a 32-year-old woman of color and early-career faculty member with a relatively youthful appearance, I have thought a great deal about how I am perceived by students and peers (Smith-Tran 2020). The way that students in the classroom and faculty in meetings react to me can have important implications regarding my perceived effectiveness as a teacher, colleague, and researcher—all of which are central to my ability to feel comfortable at work, perform to the best of my ability, and earn tenure.…”

“…It is well-documented that women faculty of color in particular are disproportionately treated and assessed in an unfair manner by students (Fries and McNinch 2003; Hamermesh and Parker 2005; Pittman 2010), and are vulnerable to mistreatment by colleagues (Turner 2002). These dynamics can potentially put even more pressure on women of color in the academy to be conscientious of how they portray themselves, and to attempt to balance coming off as friendly, approachable, and cool, yet professional, sturdy, and stoic (Smith-Tran 2020). Research indicates that simultaneously, women faculty of color are often burdened with the expectation that they serve as exemplar role models, particularly for students of color (Thomas and Hollenshead 2001).…”

The Role of Sociology Teacher in Overcoming Students’ Learning Difficulties at Sma Negeri 2 Sambi Rampa

“…The social changes that occur in today's society cannot be separated from the role of the sociology teacher, a sociology teacher essentially has a role as social control and social observer. A sociology teacher will provide an understanding and explanation of the changes that have occurred in society, especially for students and their environment (Smith-Tran, 2020).…”