Evaluating Sleep Characteristics in Intensive Care Unit and Non-Intensive Care Unit Physicians

Abstract

Healthcare workers’ cognitive performances and alertness are highly vulnerable to sleep loss and circadian rhythms. The purpose of this study was to investigate the changes in sleep characteristics of intensive care unit (ICU) and non-ICU physicians. Actigraphic sleep parameters, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, Epworth Sleepiness Scale and Hamilton Depression Rating Scale were evaluated for ICU and non-ICU physicians on the day before shift-work and on three consecutive days after shift-work. Total sleep time, sleep latency, wakefulness after sleep onset, total activity score, movement fragmentation index, sleep efficiency, daytime naps and total nap duration were also calculated by actigraph. In the ICU physicians, the mean Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index score was significantly higher than the non-ICU physicians (P=0.001), however mean Epworth Sleepiness Scale scores were not found significantly different between the two groups. None of the scores for objective sleep parameters were statistically different between the groups when evaluated before and after shift-work (P >0.05). However in both ICU and non-ICU physicians, sleep latency was observed to be decreased within the three consecutive-day period after shift-work with respect to basal values (P <0.001). Total sleep time, total activity score and sleep efficiency scores prior to shift-work were significantly different from shift-work and the three consecutive-days after shift-work, in both groups. Working in the ICU does not have an impact on objective sleep characteristics of physicians in this study. Large cohort studies are required to determine long-term health concerns of shift-working physicians.

Evaluation of sleep quality in medical faculty assistants

“…In contrast, when PSQI scores were accepted as a major indicative of low quality sleep as in our study, we didn't notice any impact of age and sex on sleep quality. Ok et al [9] in a study evaluating sleep quality in doctors working in intensive care units and other departments found no difference in objective sleep parameters defined as sleep efficacy, sleep latency and total duration of sleep, but sleep quality was worse for intensive care doctors. In our study, PSQI scores of residents training in surgical sciences were significantly higher with significantly shorter sleeping times.…”

Validation of a novel sleep-quality questionnaire to assess sleep in the coronary care unit: a polysomnography study

“…Although some studies used the PSQI to evaluate sleep in the intensive care unit [22,23], that parameter is a validated tool to address home sleep [19], but it was not designed to be used in the intensive care scenario.…”