Endoscopic scoring of mucus quantity and quality: observer and horse variance and relationship to inflammation, mucus viscoelasticity and volume

Abstract

Summary Reasons for performing study: Endoscopic scoring of airway mucus quantity and quality has not been critically assessed. Objectives: To evaluate mucus scores for 1) observer‐ and horse‐related variance and 2) association with inflammation, mucus viscoelasticity and measured volume. Methods: Variance of scoring within and between observers and over time within horses were determined for airway mucus accumulation, apparent viscosity, localisation and colour, and correlations of mucus accumulation scores with neutrophil ratios in secretions. The relationship of accumulation score to measured volumes of ‘artificial mucus’ was investigated. Correlations of mucus accumulation, apparent viscosity and colour scores with measured viscoelasticity were tested. Viscoelasticity was compared between tracheal secretion samples collected ventrally and dorsally. Results: Mucus accumulation scoring showed excellent interobserver agreement and moderate horse‐related variance, was related to measured volumes of ‘artificial mucus’, and correlated well with neutrophilic airway inflammation. Scores of mucus viscosity, colour and localisation showed high observer‐related variance. Mucus accumulation, apparent viscosity and colour scores did not correlate with measured tracheal mucus viscoelasticity, but dorsally‐localised mucus showed 2‐fold higher measured viscoelasticity than ventrally‐localised samples. Conclusions: Mucus accumulation scores are a reproducible measure of mucus volumes in the trachea. Potential relevance: Endoscopic scoring of mucus accumulation is a reliable clinical and research tool. In contrast, apparent viscosity, localisation and colour scores should be interpreted with caution.

Cytological evaluation of tracheal aspirate and broncho-alveolar lavage fluid in comparison to endoscopic assessment of lower airways in horses with recurrent airways obstruction or inflammatory airway disease

“…Similar results were obtained by Gerber et al (2004), in a study where healthy horses were exposed to dusty hay. According to our study, as well as other results, it can be implicated that determining the number of neutrophils in both washings is a more sensitive method than the evaluation of discharge accumulation.…”

Recurrent respiratory disorders in Polish Konik horses - clinical and laboratory findings

“…The increased amount and poorer quality of mucus found in the trachea of healthy horses, as well as changes in arterial blood gasometry, was probably due to poor air quality and increased respiratory rate due to noxious gases present in the stable. These observations remain in accordance with results of others authors (5,7,22).…”

Cytology profile and age influence in the equine bronchoalveolar lavage in healthy and asymptomatic inflammatory airway disease

“…The trachea was considered normal when presented intact, with shiny mucous membranes of pale color and a sharp carina (DIXON, 1997). The semi-quantitative evaluation of the tracheal mucous was conducted using a score from 0 to 5, according to GERBER et al (2004).…”