This is an author produced pre-print version of a paper later published in Animal Feed Science and Technology.Citation for the published paper: Lorenz, M.M., Udén, P. (2011) Criteria for tannin binding effects were based on N fractionation in an in vitro ruminal digestion system. A 28 mixture of sainfoin varieties were wilted to different dry matter (DM) levels and treated with 0, 4 and 8 ml 29 formic acid per kg fresh matter prior to ensiling for 60 days. Nitrogen fractionation included measurement 30 of total N, buffer soluble N, non-protein N, α-amino acid N and ammonia N. Protein degradation was 31 measured by an in vitro ruminal protein digestion system. Results show beneficial effects of moderate and 32 high acidification particularly for buffer soluble N at 180 and 400 g/kg DM (p<0.0001) while these effects 33 level off at 500 and 600 g/kg DM (P<0.852). However, no negative effect related to impaired tannin 34 protein binding in the silages or the in vitro protein degradation occurred. 35