Does a Democratic Management Model Enhance Performance through Market Orientation? Empirical Evidence from the Mondragon Industrial Group

Abstract

A management model is a set of choices made by a firm's leadership regarding how objectives are defined, efforts are motivated, activities are coordinated and resources allocated, in short, regarding how the company will be run. Just as other types of businesses do, cooperatives need to create sustainable competitive advantages by adopting market-oriented management approaches. Mondragon Corporation achieves this in an alternative way relative to the conventional organizational and governance model, combining commitments to democratic principles, solidarity and competitiveness. Inspired by changes in the expectations of worker-members, new technological capabilities and the strategies of new competitors, Mondragon Corporation has designed a distinctive management model that can itself be a key driver of its competitiveness. The research presented here is focused on market orientation (MO), its relationships with a set of internal factors found in Mondragon cooperative enterprises, and their subsequent impact on business performance. Empirical results suggest that (1) Mondragon's management model increases organizational commitment, facilitating the adoption of MO and (2) a positive impact of MO on business performance. Practical and research implications are discussed. JEL classification: J54, M31

The impact of balanced agile project management on firm performance: the mediating role of market orientation and strategic agility

“…The study by Jaworski and Kohli (1993) empirically proves that centralization has a negative effect on market-orientation, while departmentalization and formalization do not show a significant effect on market orientation. Furthermore, several studies show the positive influence of decentralization and autonomy on market orientation Agirre, Reinares and Freundlich, 2014;Barnabas and Mekoth, 2010). Therefore, the study suggests that employee empowerment at a lower level of organizations should be promoted instead of centralized decision-making in the upper level of organization management.…”

Employee Perceptions About Participation in Decision-Making in the COVID Era and Its Impact on the Psychological Outcomes: A Case Study of a Cooperative in MONDRAGON (Basque Country, Spain)

“…In fact, the three areas of participation mentioned above, are present in the cooperatives. Moreover, participation is a basic principle of their business formula and in the cooperatives within MONDRAGON, participation is the spine of the group's cooperative experience (Altuna Gabilondo, 2008) and one of its identifying features (Agirre et al, 2015). However, as mentioned before, the participation in cooperatives has some lights and shadows that literature gathers.…”

The Viability of Cooperatives: The Fall of the Mondragon Cooperative Fagor

“…The Mondragon companies became the model for successful cooperative business to follow. The extensive and varied experience of Mondragon provides a rich body of ideas and tools for cooperative development (Bradley and Gelb 1982; Miller 2002; Morrison 1997; Oakeshott 1978; Ridley-Duff 2010; Whyte and Whyte 1991) as well as for businesses who seek to foster labor-management cooperation and decentralization (Malone 2004) or to include values and the community view in consumer- and market-driven businesses (Agirre, Reinares, and Freundlich 2014; Cheney 1999; Mintzberg 2009).…”