SUMMARY Thirteen patients with severe cardiac failure underwent a single crossover study of dopamine and dobutamine in order to compare the systemic and regional hemodynamic effects of the two drugs. The dose-response data demonstrated that dobutamine (2.5-10 ,ug/kg/min) progressively and predictably increases cardiac output by increasing stroke volume, while simultaneously decreasing systemic and pulmonary vascular resistance and pulmonary capillary wedge pressure. There was no change in heart rate or premature ventricular contractions (PVCs)/min at this dose range. Dopamine (2-8 ,ug/kg/min) increased the stroke volume and cardiac output at 4 ,g/kg/min. Dopamine at >4 ,Ag/kg/min provided little additional increase in cardiac output and increased the pulmonary wedge pressure and the number of PVCs/min. At >6 Ag/kg/min, dopamine increased heart rate. During the 24-hour maintenance-dose infusion of each drug (dopamine 3.7-4, dobutamine 7.3-7.7 ,ug/kg/min), only dobutamine maintained a significant increase of stroke volume, cardiac output, urine flow, urine sodium concentration, creatinine clearance and peripheral blood flow. Renal and hepatic blood flow were not significantly altered by the maintenance dose of either drug. Systemic and regional hemodynamic data suggest that dobutamine has many advantages over dopamine when infused in patients with cardiac failure. DOPAMINE HAS REPLACED most other catecholamine preparations (e.g., isoproterenol, norepinephrine) in clinical situations where inotropic and circulatory support is required. The popularity of dopamine has, as its basis, several studies1-5 showing that dopamine is less chronotropic and has less dramatic peripheral vascular effects than the other catecholamines. In addition, dopamine appears to have a unique property of stimulating renovascular receptors (dopaminergic receptors) directly.3 6-10 Tuttle and Mills" have systematically formulated and synthesized a new catecholamine, dobutamine, designed to selectively increase cardiac contractility without altering heart rate and blood pressure.Animal and human data'2-18 indicate that dobutamine increases stroke volume, cardiac output and overall cardiocirculatory performance in a dose range that does not elicit significant chronotropic and peripheral vascular responses. Dobutamine has also improved some parameters of renal function in patients with severe cardiac failure."8 Acute hemodynamic studies (catheterization laboratory data) comparing dopamine and dobutamine19 20 suggest that the ventricular function of patients with heart failure improves with both agents; however, dobutamine appears to be less chronotropic and, in contrast to dopamine, tends to lower left ventricular filling pressure. This study was designed to compare the dose-hemodynamic response curves, the maintenance dose-systemic and regional responses (during a 24-hour infusion) and the withdrawal responses of dopamine and dobutamine in 13 patients with low output cardiac failure.
Methods and Materials
PatientsThirteen patients with modera...